波士顿法律 前情提要 Previously on Boston legal
你打扰到我了 You disapprove of me.
Sally 你知道的 你得离Shore那小子远点 You know, I'd stake out a little distance from that Shore guy, Sally.
他总能让人在遇见他后 变得更加糟糕 He tends to leave people's minds a little worse off than he finds them.
为什么你要让Sally跟我保持距离 Why are you counseling Sally to distance herself from me
有些男人分手后留下快乐 There are happily ever after guys,
有些却只给女生留下痛苦 and there are those who leave girls in a heap.
我能分辨出来 And I can tell the difference.
抱歉 我迟到了 好人们 Sorry, I'm sorry, good people.
Edwin 你还好吗 Edwin, everything all right
好到不行 Hunky dory.
Denny 我要跟Tara一起上庭的 Denny, guess what, I'm due in court with Tara.
我们会接手的 We're on it.
不要担心 Don't you worry.
你只要赶紧康复就好 好的 You just get better. Okay.
把他的停车通行证作废 Demagnetize his parking pass.
你说什么 我知道人什么时候该离开 I beg your pardon I know when the man is gone.
Helen Helen.
他走了 He's gone.
Denny Edwin走了 Denny, Edwin's gone.
我知道 我很遗憾 I know. Shame.
不 我是说他失踪了 No, I mean he's missing.
他离开了医院 He left the hospital.
他来过这里吗 据我所知没有 Did he come here Not that I'm aware of.
有谁见到过Edwin Poole吗 Anyone see Edwin Poole
法官大人 现在我决定解雇我的辩护律师 Your honor, at this time I would like to discharge counsel.
你能告诉我你为什么需要新的辩护律师吗 Can you tell me why you want new counsel
我没办法再忍受下去了 On the grounds of intolerabilitude.
Litch先生 这算不上理由 Not a real word, Mr. Litch.
这就是理由 法官大人 It should be, your honor,
因为这能够说明 because it describes my deteriorating relationship
我和那个需要证明我清白的人之间不断恶化的关系 with the man vested with the responsibility of proving my innocence.
先生 你已经认罪了 Sir, you confessed to the crime.
我改变主意了 I changed my position on that.
Litch先生 这已经是第七个你在庭审 Mr. Litch, this is the seventh attorney
前一天解雇的律师了 you've sought to discharge on the eve of trial.
法官大人 我很期盼上庭的那一天 Your honor, I am anxious for my day in court.
我很期待看到12个开明的人坐在那边位子上 I'm looking forward to seeing 12 open minds in that box,
因为当你坐在这里的时候我一个也看不到 because I don't see one when you're sitting,
而且也没这样的一个人和我坐在一起 and I don't have one sitting here with me.
好吧 现在我的问题是 Litch先生 Well, here's my problem, Mr. Litch.
我已经没有公派辩护律师给你了 I'm all out of public defenders.
每一个能用的都被你炒掉了 Every available one, you fired.
我来接这个案子 I'll do it.
我是Crane, Poole & Schmidt 律师事物所的辩护律师Edwin Poole Attorney Edwin Poole, your honor, of Crane, Poole & Schmidt.
我会为Litch先生辩护 I'll represent Mr. Litch.
你就是那个Edwin Poole You're the Edwin Poole
没错 Indeed.
来自Crane, Poole & Schmidt律师事物所 From Crane, Poole & Schmidt
没错 Indeed.
你主动要求为这个男人辩护 And you're offering to defend this man.
是的 Yes.
Litch先生 我现在给你一个新的辩护律师 Mr. Litch, I will give you a new attorney.
但是我不会再给你额外的时间了 What I will not give you is additional time.
审判将于明天开始 This trial will begin tomorrow
我能要求保释听证会吗 法官大人 May I be heard on bail, judge
不 你不行 明天上午10点 No, you may not. 10:00 tomorrow.
被告继续羁押 Defendant stays in custody.
现在休庭 We are adjourned.
你好 罪犯先生 Hello, Mr. Criminal.
我们到拘留所里再谈 We can talk back in custody.
顺便问一下 你的罪名是 Incidentally, what are you charged with
谋杀 Murder.
你给自己揽到一个头号重犯 You got yourself a top-of-the-line criminal.
他做了什么 他接了个案子 He did what He took a case.
离开医院 闯入刑事法庭 然后接了这个案子 Left the hospital, went into criminal session, and took a case.
我们需要你来跟进 哇喔 We need you to get down there. Whoa.
不 别说 哇喔 No, never mind Whoa.
我不跟刑事案 我有案子 抽不开身 I do not do criminal law. I can't go. I'm in trial.
我们还有很多律师 你当过地方检查官 We have lots of other lawyers. You used to be a D.A.
你能做到的 Alan Shore呢 他能 You can do it. What about Alan Shore He's
Lewiston需要他做别的事 Lewiston needs him for something else.
我需要你来跟这个案子 拜托了 I need you to get down there, please.
他现在坐在拘留所的号子里 He is sitting in a jail cell.
什么叫做他现在坐在拘留所的号子里 What do you mean he's sitting in a jail cell
他回到拘留所 进了号子 He walked back into custody, went into the cell.
然后他坐在了委托人旁边 就是这样 There he sits with the client, happily so.
拜托你跟这个案子 Please get down there.
那么这件事到底是怎样 So what's it about
完全没有头绪 I have no idea.
好吧 如果你需要我协助 Well, if you need a second chair,
Paul Lewiston就会知道我的存在了 it would be nice for Paul Lewiston to know that I exist.
Denny Crane在此 久仰 Denny Crane. You got it.
有什么可以效劳的 What can I do for you
谢谢 请坐 Thank you. Please have a seat.
我们要为一个公司CEO辩护 We represent a company, the CEO
需要紧急的法律援助 of which is in need of immediate legal assistance.
Lee Tyler 睿智的女士 Lee Tyler, brilliant woman.
和蔼的女士 Kind woman.
同时也有盗窃癖 Also a kleptomaniac.
她明天将面临因偷窃一条200美金 的围巾指控 She's about to go on trial tomorrow for stealing a $200 scarf.
本该是件小事 但是这次不同 It's ordinarily a small matter. Here's why it's not.
如果她被定罪 If she gets convicted of this crime,
她就违反了公司合同中的道德条款 she violates a morals clause in her contract.
她就不能继续担任CEO She's out as CEO,
但是因为她是我们的雇主 and since she's the one who hired us,
我们就会丢掉最大的客户 we stand to lose our biggest client.
我们不得不 We have
竭尽全力以所有常规方式帮她脱罪 exhausted all conventional means to make this go away.
但我们失败了 We have failed.
现在我们需要的是一个在打破常规方面 We now need an attorney with experience in, perhaps
经验丰富的律师 unconventional means.
我不在乎 I don't care.
你不在乎 You don't care
他基本上是从精神病院逃出来的 He basically escaped from a mental facility.
反对 Objection.
你们说话就象我根本不在这房间里 这是不应该的 You're talking as if I'm not even in the room. It's inappropriate.
没别的意思 Edwin 你真的不该在这里 No offense, Edwin, but you shouldn't be in the room.
你应该呆在医院 You should still be in the hospital.
听着 Colson女士 Look, Ms. Colson,
你的公司接了这个案子 your firm took this case.
如果Edwin Poole不能接的话 那就落到你头上了 If Edwin Poole lacks capacity to try it, then it falls to you.
我 我不接刑事案子的 Me I don't practice criminal law.
律师小姐 我已经受够了 Counsel, I have had it.
这个案子已经拖了很久了 This case has been perversely delayed.
我已经让一位寡妇和她的2个孩子 4次到场参与审判 I've had a widow and her two children show up for trial four times,
每次都以延期收场 only to have it put off.
我不能再让它拖下去了 I won't delay it another day.
他不做 你做 If he can't do it, then you will.
现在 我建议你们去见当事人吧 Now, I suggest you get back there and meet your client.
他做个停止的手势让我停下 He pulls me over for running this stop sign,
而我拿着一小包可卡因 你知道 所以 and I got this dime bag of coke, you know, so
我把东西藏在座位底下不让他看见 I stuff it under my seat so he can't see it.
我的枪也放在那 I also got my gun under there.
他是个毒贩 He's a drug dealer.
继续 Continue.
然后他来到我窗边 So he comes to the window
说了一堆交通安全的大道理 and gives me this and that about road safety and all that,
然后让我从车里出来 and then he tells me to step out of the car,
突然间 我想到 见鬼 他肯定会搜车的 and suddenly, I'm thinking, damn, he's gonna search it,
加上两次前科 我死定了 and two priors for intent, I'm a dead man.
再来第三次 That's strike three.
要坐一辈子牢的 It's a life sentence.
我慌了 So I panicked.
我从座位底下 I reached under the seat,
摸到了枪 然后对他开了枪 I grabbed the gun, and I shot him.
砰 Boom
然后 So
继续 Continue.
我那时慌了 I panicked.
我甚至都不记得了 我说的都是实话 I don't even remember it. I'm telling you the truth.
一想到无期徒刑 In one second, I'm thinking life sentence,
接下来我就扣动了扳机 and the next thing, I'm squeezing the trigger.
然后呢 呃 我开车跑了 And then what happened Well, I drove off,
我看新闻说他们展开了大搜捕 and I'm seeing on the news how they had this big manhunt
找到了车牌的一部分 and they had a partial license plate,
我意识到找到我只是时间问题 so I figured it was only a matter of time.
一周以后 我家的门被轰开 One week later, my door's busted in.
我想要从窗户逃出去 但那时我就被击中了 I try to go out the window, and that's when I got shot.
最后 我在医院里全招了 Finally, I just confessed to it all in the hospital.
他们没找到枪 They don't have the gun.
没枪 没目击证人 No gun, no witnesses.
他们啥证据都没有 They ain't got nothing.
除了你的供词 Except your confession.
是的 Yeah.
罪犯先生 虽然我从不喜欢预言什么 Mr. Criminal, I don't ever like to make predictions,
但是我想我们能把你弄出去 but I think we can get you off.
我问她我能检查一下她的包吗 I asked her if I could look in her bag.
她对我说 She said to me,
你有什么权利这么做 what right do you have
我说 女士 我是这家商场的保安 I said, well, ma'am, I'm a security officer for the store.
接下来发生了什么 先生 And then what happened, sir
她让我检查了她的包 She let me look in her bag,
里面果然有那条围巾 and there was the scarf.
她说了什么吗 Did she say anything
她说她不知道围巾怎么到她的包里去的 Said she had no idea how it got there.
告诉我 Lyne先生 Tell me, Mr. Lyne,
你从多远外看到被告把围巾放她包里 from what distance did you see the accused put the scarf in her bag
我本人并没有看见 I didn't actually see it myself.
哦 你并没有看见 是 Oh, you didn't see it. No.
一个商场职员说是她拿的 A store clerk said she took it.
啊 那好吧 Ah, there we go.
你看见那个职员今天到场了吗 是的 我看见了 Do you see the store clerk here today, sir Yes, I do.
Miles Tibbet 就坐在那儿 Miles Tibbet, sitting right over there.
这个男人 告诉你被告拿了那条围巾 This man. He told you the defendant took the scarf.
是的 是他告诉我的 Yes, he did.
你觉得秘密进行间谍工作如何 How do you feel about working undercover
什么 I'm sorry
案子的关键就是那个店员 Their entire case is a store clerk.
我决定对他进行个人调查 跟踪他 I want to put a private investigator on him, follow him.
我们找机会接近他 比如共进午餐 We pick the opportunity for you to meet him, lunch, perhaps.
然后呢 Denny Crane在此 And then what Denny Crane.
然后你点些开胃菜和饭前酒 漫不经心地透露出一些讯息 Then you order appetizers, elicit some disparaging information,
让他相信你可以是任何人 allowing him to believe you're anyone at all
但绝对不会是被告的辩护律师 other than the defendant's lawyer.
这样公平吗 Is that fair
我不明白你这个问题 I don't understand the question.
他说他是看着Perry Mason长大的 He says he grew up watching Perry Mason,
而且发誓有朝一日 一定要做刑事案件 and he promised himself he would one day do a criminal trial.
当然 你不会由着他来的 Certainly you're not going to let him.
他看起来心智还在 He seems to have his wits about him.
事实上 也许他比我还有把握 The truth is is he's probably more equipped than me.
我想最好的办法就是我来监督 然后让他来首席辩护 I think the best thing would be for me to supervise and let him first chair.
Edwin Edwin.
Paul Paul.
你真的认为你能搞定这个吗 You really think you're up to this
我在法学院时做过实习 I did clinical work in law school.
有关证据的规矩和民事法的一样 The rules of evidence are the same as civil.
没什么神秘的 There's no great mystery to it.
而且 Also
昨晚我梦见他了 he came to me in a dream last night,
他告诉我接下这案子 and he told me to try this case.
上帝吗 God
著名法庭推理小说主人公 Perry Perry.
还是我来做首席吧 I'll first chair.
要点什么 Can I help you
随便什么都行 Whatever's on tap.
了解 I got it.
你好吗 How's it going
不错 谢谢 Fine, thank you.
我是Sally Sally.
你很 You're
很漂亮 但是我不 very beautiful, but I don't
做那种事情的 do that sort of thing.
哪种事情 What sort of thing
天哪 你 你认为我是妓女 What, you, you think I'm a hooker
你的酒 Here you go.
不好意思 你能帮我把这个扔他脸上吗 Excuse me, can you throw that in this man's face
我很抱歉 但是 I'm sorry, but
但是通常漂亮的女生是不会接近我 but beautiful women don't usually come up to me
跟我打招呼 除非 and say hi unless
好吧 就怪我觉得你看起来还算正派 Well, excuse me for thinking you look like a decent guy.
你知道一个女生只想安安静静 Do you know how hard it is for a girl to just
喝杯啤酒而不被色狼骚扰有多难吗 go out for a quiet beer by herself without being attacked by wolves
我觉得你看起来是个好人 又有安全感 I thought you looked safe and nice.
你却把我当妓女 And you call me a hooker.
什么收获 Learn anything
就只有他一生的经历 Only his whole life story,
没人会想给他改编成电影的 相信我 and no one is bidding for the movie rights, trust me.
他收集名人签名 已经积累了1200多张 He collects autographs, has almost 1,200 of them,
包括一整套Mamma Mia 演员签名 including the entire cast of Mamma Mia national tour.
啊 还有 他对贝类过敏 还要听吗 Oh, yes, and he's allergic to shellfish. Want more
是的 真是帮大忙了 Yes. This is very helpful.
喂 你好 Hello
是他打来的 It's him.
嗨 Miles 你还好吗 Hi, Miles. How's it going
我们很希望能够提供证人 We would like to be able to offer you witnesses.
但不幸的是 只有两个 Unfortunately, there were only two.
一个已经死了 而另一个正在被审判 One's dead, and the other's on trial.
好消息是他已经认罪 The good news is he confessed,
虽然他现在想要否认 though he now wants to recant.
你们会听到那个记录供词的警官的说明 You will hear from the officer who listened to that confession,
然后你们就会信服 and you will find it reliable.
你们会发现这些都是和事实一致的 You will find it consistent with the truth,
事实就是 在7月17号那一天 the truth that on July 17th,
被告Warren Litch射杀了警官Michael Deveraux the defendant Warren Litch shot dead officer Michael Deveraux.
早上好 Good morning.
我是Lori Colson My name is Lori Colson
法官大人 现在我想要解雇我的辩护律师 Your honor, at this time, I would like to discharge counsel.
驳回 那么 我觉得有必要申明 Denied. In that case, it should be known
这个女人到昨天之前甚至都没见过我 that this woman didn't even bother to meet me until yesterday.
我自己的律师甚至不知道我的名字 My own lawyer, She didn't even know my name.
她不够专业 她毫无准备 She is unprofessional, she is unprepared,
而最重要的是 她肉太多了 and on top of that, she's fleshy.
我的辩护律师要苗条 骨感 对正义如饥似渴 I want me a thin, wiry attorney, somebody hungry for justice.
更换律师提议驳回 Motion for new counsel denied.
法官大人 我能和我的委托人谈会儿吗 May I have a moment with my client, your honor
请 Please.
你到底在做什么 What the hell was that
我不喜欢陪审团的眼光 I didn't like the look of the jury.
我想要一个无效审判 I was going for a mistrial.
但是你得不到 是吧 Well, you didn't get one, did you
你的所作所为只是疏远陪审团 顺便毁谤我个人 All you did was alienate them and undermine me in the process.
你想进监狱吗 Do you want to go to prison
小姐 我是进定了 Lady, I'm going to prison.
我打死了一个警察 I shot a cop.
牢是坐定了 No doubt I'm going to prison.
我这辈子就剩下这场审判了 The only real living I got left is in this trial business,
我很乐意永远地折腾下去 and I'm happy to stretch it out forever.
你认为这是场游戏 让你最后耍一把 You think this is some game for you, to have your last joyride
Colson小姐 我杀了一个人 I killed a man, miss Colson.
我看到他的遗孀坐在那 我也看到了他的孩子 And I see his widow sitting in there, and I see his kids.
我知道这不是游戏 I know this ain't no game.
孩子 Son
如果我能问一句 if I might ask
为什么你说她肉太多 why did you call her fleshy
我只是想幽默她一下 I was just trying to humanize her.
陪审团不喜欢漂亮的女士 Juries don't like beautiful women.
你认为我肉多吗 You think I'm fleshy
现在还能做成什么交易吗 比如协议 Is there any deal to be made here, a plea
他们不需要什么交易 Warren 你已经认罪了 They don't need to deal, Warren. You confessed.
现在什么都是徒劳 Another curious strategic move.
我认罪是因为他们耍了我 I only confessed because they tricked me.
你什么意思 他们耍了你 What do you mean, they tricked you
他们让医生对我说我快死了 They got the doctor to tell me I was about to die,
然后他们派了个卧底警察 and then they sent in this cop undercover
假装成医院的牧师 pretending to be the hospital chaplain,
对我说生前不坦白所有罪过 and he laid it on thick with the whole confess thy sins
死后不能上天堂 or there's no heaven for me.
他们骗你说你快死了 来让你认罪 They told you you were dying to get you to confess
嗯 Yeah.
然后他就在庭上指着我 And then he pointed to me, right in open court.
你怎么做的 What'd you do
我只是尽量坐得笔直 显得无所畏惧 I just tried to sit straight and undaunted.
我是公诉的主要证人 你知道的 The chief witness for the prosecution, you know.
那不是很刺激吗 Isn't it exciting
的确 It is.
我 I
我甚至请了我的一些朋友 你了解的 来旁听 I even invited a few of my friends to, you know, come watch.
你真的这样做了 这是很蠢 但是这是我生平第一次 You did It's silly, I know, but this is the first time
受到所有人的关注 I've been at the center of, of anything.
我相信你能做得很好 I'm sure you'll do fine.
真的吗 是的 Really Mm.
是的 我 我想我会太紧张的 Yeah. I, I don't think I'll get too nervous.
我服用阻滞剂来缓解忧虑 I take beta blockers for anxiety.
零售业压力肯定很大 Retail must be very stressful.
是的 但是我就是喜欢 Yes, but I love it.
可能你会想为什么我请你吃午饭 Listen, um, you're probably wondering why I asked you to lunch.
我只是 I just
我 我没有交往过很多女人 I, I don't meet too many women.
我发誓不是像你想的那样 It's not what you think, I swear.
我不是想跟你约会什么的 I'm not about to ask you out on a date or anything,
但是我很想告诉你 but I did want to tell you
昨晚对我来说是多么有意义 how much last night meant to me.
有什么意义 我们就一起喝了啤酒 What did it mean We drank beer.
Sally Sally
一个漂亮的女士和我说话 for, for a beautiful woman to talk to me
那3个小时就好象 for three hours as if
我真的是一个有趣的人 I were an interesting person,
就好象我的人生真的那么有趣 as if my life were interesting
那对我来说意义重大 That meant something to me.
我想说的是 我 That's really all I wanted to say. I,
我很感激 I'm grateful.
干杯 Cheers.
Denny Denny.
你12点半过来一下 最多5分钟就好 I need you at 12:30. It'll take five minutes, tops.
我需要一点你的气魄 你的威势 I need to trade a little on your prominence, your heft.
你想我做什么 What do you want me to do
啥都不说 啥都不做 I don't want you to do anything or say anything.
只要你在就行 I just want you to be.
只要做你自己 Be all that you can be.
一句话 骄傲 One of the few, the proud.
你不需要我说什么吗 You don't want me to say anything
只要那两个词就能让人敬畏了 Just those two little words that tend to shock and awe.
Denny Crane Denny Crane.
你可以尽情的嘲笑我 不过你休想侮辱我们的团队 Feel free to mock me all you want, but don't you dare ridicule our troops.
确认一下 我可以尽情嘲笑你是吧 Just so I'm clear, I should feel free to mock you.
他说过那时他完全慌了 He basically said that he panicked.
再次定罪就会满三次 His next conviction was strike three.
他将面临终生监禁 所以他慌了 He'd be looking at a life sentence, and he just panicked.
说到慌了 你是指 And by panicked, you mean
他伸到座位下 拿起武器 he reached under the seat, retrieved the weapon,
对着警员开枪 and shot the officer.
他告诉你说他开枪打了Deveraux警官吗 He told you he shot officer Deveraux
是的 先生 Yes, sir.
他请求我宽恕他 He asked me to forgive him,
而且请求上帝宽恕他 and he asked god to forgive him.
谢谢你 警官 Thank you, officer.
法官大人 现在我想 Your honor, at this time, I would
坐下 Sit
我只想提醒陪审团 Just to remind the jury,
我当事人在告诉你这一切的时候 at the time my client said all of this to you,
他觉得自己快死了 he thought he was dying.
是的 女士 Yes, ma'am.
而他认为你是医院的牧师 And he thought you were the hospital chaplain
是的 女士 Yes, ma'am.
谢谢你 警官 Thank you, officer.
就这样 That's it
2个问题 那就是你的问讯 Two questions. That was your cross
我没什么好问他的 Warren I didn't have much to cross him with, Warren.
那你这些问题的重点在哪 Then what was the point of your questions
告诉我 我在证明你是被迫承认的 Tell me that. I was trying to establish that you were coerced.
法官不会容易动摇 也许陪审团会 The judge doesn't shock easily, but maybe the jury does.
哦 我了解 你想制造点冲击效果 Oh, I see. You were going for shock value.
好吧 也许你真的能办到 Well, maybe you could have really gone for it
如果你问3个问题 and asked three questions.
嗨 Warren 如果你看我不顺眼 Hey, Warren, if you're unhappy with me
那又怎样 Then what
法官不让我请别的人了 The judge isn't gonna let me hire anybody else.
你是我全部的希望 女士 You're all I got, lady.
你是我的全部希望 You're all I got.
感谢你的到来 我是Alan Shore Well, thank you so much for coming, Alan Shore.
地方检查官说我没必要跟你谈的 The D.A. said I didn't have to talk to you.
如果愿意的你话 我将不胜感激 Which only compounds my gratitude for your choosing to do so.
到我办公室去吧 Let's go to my office.
什么事情 What's this about
不管你相不相信 这是你最感兴趣的事 Miles Well, believe it or not, it's about your best interest, Miles.
天啊 我的办公室还真是遥远 Gosh, my office seems so far away.
干脆还是到这间好了 Let's go to this one over here instead.
也许你们见过 Sally过来认识一下 Sally Heep, Miles Tibbet. Perhaps you've met.
她为我工作 Sally gets around. She works with me.
当然你肯定听说过这位先生 And certainly you've heard of this gentleman.
不用我介绍了 Denny Crane He needs no introdtion. Denny Crane.
请坐吧 Please have a seat.
Alan Alan
谢谢你 Sally 现在我来处理就好 Thank you, Sally, I'll take it from here.
你已经尽力了 You've done more than your share.
Miles 我们长话短说吧 Let's make this brief, Miles.
我们的当事人被指控从你的商场 We represent a woman who is charged with stealing a scarf
偷了条围巾 from the store where you work,
正好被你看到全部过程 which is precisely what she did. You saw the whole thing.
现在我们进退两难 Miles So we find ourselves between a rock and a hard place, Miles.
一面是我们的客户 财富五百强公司的CEO The rock being our client, CEO of a fortune 500 company
清楚地表示唯一可以接受的判决 只有无罪释放 who has made it abundantly clear the only acceptable verdict is not guilty.
另一面就是你了 Miles 我们的目击证人 And the hard place being you, Miles, the eyewitness.
但是也许你不会太为难我们 是吧 But maybe you aren't so hard after all Am I right
我不太清楚 I'm not sure what you want.
Sally告诉我的一些信息 真令人遗憾 Sally has given me some information which, regrettably,
按道理说我应该在法庭上攻击你的 I'm ethically required to attack you with in court.
比如说 既然我知道你因忧虑而服用阻滞剂 For example, since I know you take beta blockers for your anxiety.
其副作用可能会让人头晕 或神志不清 some possible side effects being dizziness, confusion,
我就有责任提出来 I am duty bound to raise it.
而且 关于你邀请 Also, the idea that you invited
一些朋友到庭旁听你做证 a few friends down to the courthouse to hear you testify
如果我对此不做一点小猜测的话 就是我的失职了 it would be malpractice for me not to make a small snack of that.
当然我必须提到你的自卑感和 Of course, I'll have to get into your inferiority complex and
如果那姑娘笑了 那她肯定是个妓女之类的事情 Staff about If the girl smiles, she must be a hooker that sort of thing.
但是我从来没说过 But I never said
我在说话 Miles I'm talking, Miles.
Alan Alan
我在说话 Sally I'm talking, Sally.
你收集签名 Sally 那肯定很有趣 You collect autographs, Miles. That must be fun.
在凄风冷雨夜里游荡 Standing around on cold, drizzly nights
就为了等那些名人的匆匆一瞥 waiting for famous people to give you a cursory glance,
如果他们同情你的话 也许他们会花上那么点时间的 a moment of their time, perhaps, if they take pity on you.
你经常得到人们的同情吗 Miles Do people often take pity on you, Miles
我不感到奇怪 我看到的确实如此 It wouldn't surprise me. I'm seeing a pattern here.
可怜 忧虑 自卑 所有那些悲伤的词汇 Pity, anxiety, inferiority all those ity words.
这不公平 你说对了 的确不公平 This isn't fair You're right, it's not.
但是你要做好你的工作 我也要 But you have a job to do and so do I.
你的是卖袜子和吊袜带 Yours is to sell socks and suspenders.
我的是交叉询问像你这样的人 然后碾碎他们 Mine is to cross-examine people like you and crush them.
如果我不这样做 这个男人就会把我炒掉 This man here would fire me if I didn't.
Denny Crane Denny Crane.
他会炒了我 Miles He would fire me, Miles,
如果我没在你坐证人席上的几小时内 if I didn't explore every nuance and shadow of your personality,
把你性格上的任何一点微妙扭曲和阴暗部分 every secret place and insufficiency in the hours
以及每一个秘密角落揭发出来 that you will spend in that witness chair, Miles,
当着所有你请来的朋友的面 in front of all those friends you invited.
当我结束对你的问讯后 And when I'm finished with you,
甚至连他们也会相信你是个可悲的可怜虫 even they will believe you are a vindictive, pathetic little sycophant
错误地指控 who has falsely accused,
也许是诬陷了一位受人尊敬的女士 and probably framed a fine woman
她从没做过的罪名 for something she never did and never would do
因为只有这样 你才能抓住这仅有 的机会获得大家的关注 only so that you could get, at long last, your moment of attention.
当我做到那个地步的时候 By the time I'm done,
我会让你相信是你自己 把那条围巾放进她的包里 I'll have you believing you put that scarf in her handbag.
Lee Tyler请得起世界上任何一个辩护律师 Lee Tyler can afford to hire any attorney in the world.
她选择了我 She's chosen me.
你想知道我好在哪里吗 Miles Do you wonder if I'm any good, Miles
你真的想知道 Do you really wonder
能和你谈会吗 我不想和你说话 Alan May I speak with you a moment I don't wanna speak with you, Alan.
如果我告诉你Miles会来 我不想和你说话 If I told you Miles was coming I do not want to speak with you.
请你走开行吗 Can you please walk away
Sally 那不是什么让人愉快的谈话 Sally, that was not a pleasant meeting.
一般来说 当我的伙伴不高兴的时候 我会给他们一个拥抱 Typically, when associates are unhappy, I give them a hug.
Crane先生 我不需要什么拥抱 I don't want a hug, Mr. Crane.
好吧 Okay.
那你能给我一个吗 May I have one
他们告诉我他是信教的 They told me that he was religious,
当他意识到自己快死的时候也许 that maybe if he though the was about to die,
他的良心会让他作出正确选择 his conscience would get the better of him.
所以你告诉Litch先生他快死了 So you told Mr. Litch was dying.
是的 我并不以此为荣 Yeah. I'm not proud of it,
但是我也许应该 but I probably should have
医生 你听到Litch先生承认 and, doctor, did you also hear Mr. Litch
是他杀了Deveraux警官吗 confess to killing officer Deveraux
是的 Yes.
你确定 You're sure
非常肯定 I'm very positive.
谢谢你 医生 Thank you, doctor.
他骗你你还能活多久 Okay, how long had he treated you before
事实上 你告诉他活不过一个小时 In fact, you told him he had less than an hour to live.
是的 Yes.
你对你自己的病人撒谎 You lied to your own patient
他们告诉我他谋杀了一位警官 They told me that he had murdered a police officer
作为这种卑鄙行为的后果 As a result of this despicable conduct,
你受到医院的处罚了吗 were you disciplined by the hospital
我的执照被暂停了3个月 My privileges were suspended for three months.
而你现在已经回到急诊室了 And you're back in the E.R. now.
不 不 No, no.
我只是开始在神经科做住院医生 I've started my residency in the neurology department.
你的专长是脑科 Your specialty is the brain.
是的 医生 作为一名神经科专家 Yes. Doctor, as a neurologist,
外伤和大量失血会对大脑产生什么影响 how does trauma and extensive blood loss affect the brain
呃 有时会损害精神官能 Uh, sometimes it can compromise mental function.
会让人产生错觉吗 Can it cause a person to become delusional
我不认为那天晚上他是产生错觉 I don't believe he was delusional that night.
他的确是受了外伤还有大量失血吗 是的 Did he suffer trauma and extensive blood loss Yes.
是的 他的确如此 但是我 Yes, he, he did, but I
你能作出确切的医学诊断来证明他 没有产生错觉吗 can you state to a medical certainty that he was not delusional
不能 No.
最后一个问题 请你做为一个医学外行 一个普通人来考虑 One last question and this one I ask you as a layperson, a human being.
是否有可能 你所爱的人惊慌失措 Is it conceivable to you that if you had a loved one who had panicked
犯下了一桩可怕的罪案 比如谋杀 and committed a horrible crime, say, murder
而他是你所深爱的人 你的兄弟 你最好的朋友 if somebody you cared deeply for, perhaps a brother, best friend,
也许是你的儿子 做了这么可怕的事情 maybe your son had done thihorrible thing,
而你躺在医院的病床上 奄奄一息 and you lay in a hospital bed dying,
是否有可能 你知道自己将不久于人世 Is it conceivable that knowing you were dying,
会认下自己从没做过的事情 you might take the blame for something you didn't do
就只为了帮你所爱的人免去 一生的牢狱之灾 just to spare your loved one a life sentence
反对 反对有效 Objection Sustained.
医生 那天晚上是否听到 Did it ever occur to you that night, doctor
Warren Litch说他认罪 Warren Litch said he committed the crime
只是为了保护其他人 simply to protect somebody else
不 没有这回事 No. No, it didn't.
我打赌警察也不会注意 I bet it never occurred to the police, either.
我问完了 Nothing further.
Preston先生 Mr. Preston
原告请求休庭 法官大人 The prosecution rests, your honor.
Colson女士 Ms. Colson
被告同意休庭 法官大人 The defense rests, your honor.
为什么不让我做证 How do I not get in that chair
Edwin已经做得很好了 Edwin did a good job.
如果我不说我没做 他们就不会 If I don't say I didn't do it, they're not
我不能让你那么做 为什么 I can't put you in that chair. Why
因为你的确杀了人 Because you did do it,
我不能让证人撒谎 and I can't put a witness in the chair to lie.
我有做证的权利 I have a right to testify.
但你必须陈述事实 But it would have to be in the narrative.
最好的情况 你的话自相矛盾 Best case scenario, you'll trip all over yourself.
最坏的情况 一名陪审员发现你矛盾的原因 Worst case, one of the jurors will know why it's in the narrative.
那你为什么不能问我问题 让我 And why can't you ask me questions that would allow
因为我不能 Because I can't.
行有行规 Warren We have rules, Warren.
其中一条就是我不能明知你会撒谎 还让你作证 One is I cannot put you up there to knowingly lie.
我们最好的策略就是抓住 Our best strategy here would be to argue
公诉人没有履行他们的义务这一点 the prosecution didn't satisfy its burden.
我已经是命悬一线了 This is my life on the line here,
你还跟我讨论规则 惯例 and you keep talking about a system of rules and regulations
我这么做是为了我的后半生 I'm in this for my life here.
你的责任也应该让你这么做 And you're supposed to be in this for my life, too.
我不会 Well, I'm not.
别误会 我会帮你做最好的辩护 Don't get me wrong, I will give you the very best defense I know how,
但我不会允许自己做其他事情 but I will not allow myself to be in this for you.
我会在我立志效忠的体系里 I will play my part in a system
扮演好我的角色 that I have an enormous allegiance to,
但是我决不会为你再做其他的 but I will never be in this for you.
嗨 Hey.
你今天做的很棒 Edwin That was pretty awesome today, Edwin.
人们都忘记我是个有才华的律师了 People forget I'm a brilliant trial attorney.
我可以是疯子 但依旧才华横溢 I can be nuts and still brilliant.
结案陈词你要怎么做 How do you feel about closing
如果你能像交叉询问那样陈词 那么 If you can close like you crossed, then
Perry的强项 结案陈词 That was Perry's strength, you know, the closing.
你怎么想 What do you think
我说过会让他无罪释放的 I told the man I'd get him a not guilty,
我还是有始有终的好 I might as well see it through.
这很难 不是吗 It's hard, isn't it
什么很难 What is
帮助一个罪大恶极的人 Coming to care for a person who committed such a heinous act.
有时候不违背自己的意志做事真的很难 It's hard to reconcile what we do and who we are sometimes.
我不是在乎他 I don't care about him.
我只是在做自己的工作 I'm just doing a job.
你知道 当Perry做结案陈词时 他肯定会把矛头指向凶手 You know, in Perry's closings, he would point to the real killer.
我要那么做吗 I don't suppose I should do that, should I
Tibbet是个好人 Alan 很正派 Tibbet's a good man, Alan, decent.
他只是在做他的工作 He was just doing his job.
是的 他是 你我都是 Yes, he was, and so were you, and so was I.
而你陷害他之后 就这么一走了之 And after ambushing him, you can just shake it off
我没那么做 I'm not shaking anything off.
Miles Tibbet今天过得很糟 Miles Tibbet had a very bad day.
我今天也很难熬 Alan I had a bad day, too, Alan.
我被利用了 I was taken advantage of.
或者你根本就没考虑到我 Or don't you considersending me
这样不明不白地就被耍了 to go hit on some guy at a bartaking advantage
我本来不打算这样的 It has nothing to with what I consider.
随便你怎么说 Whatever.
对你真正在意的人 你是不会这么做的 It's not the kind of thing you ask of someone that you care about.
你在乎我吗 Alan Do you care about me, Alan
非常地在乎 I care a great deal for you.
所以我才要给你一个忠告 That's why I'm gonna give you some very sound advice.
离开吧 Run.
什么 这工作很肮脏 What This is a bad business.
充满了丑陋 It is an often filthy,
没有人性 卑鄙的勾当 dehumanizing, mean-spirited job.
我没有从中得到乐趣 I assure you I take no pleasure in it.
我只是很容易适应 It just comes easily to me.
但是 But
你 you
不是那种人 are not that way.
所以我建议你仔细的好好想想 So I suggest you think long and hard
你是否真的愿意每天早上醒来 about whether you really wanna wake up every morning,
带着晨祷时许下的所有承诺 with all the promise that morning conveys,
来到这里 and come here.
我这么告诉你 Which I say to you
完全是因为我在乎你 only because I care.
你这个大骗子 You are such a liar,
假装这些事情根本不会影响到你 pretending that this stuff doesn't affect you,
你能就这么抛在脑后 that you can just brush it off.
我想我可以 I'm afraid I can.
你们已经听过Frank Simmons的证词了 You heard from witness Frank Simmons,
大约就在凶案发生时 who saw an SUV speed by him
他在离案发现场一英里处 看见一辆SUV飞快地驶离 a mile from the scene around the time of the murder
车牌是以3L6开头的 with a license plate beginning with 3L6.
Litch先生的SUV牌照也是以3L6开头 Mr. Litch's SUV has a license plate beginning with 3L6.
而当警察闯入被告的公寓时 And when the police entered the defendant's apartment,
他是什么反应 what did he do
他没有问 这是怎么回事 He didn't ask, what's this about
没有问 嘿 你们要干吗 He didn't say, hey, what's going on
他很清楚为什么警察会出现 He knew exactly why they were there.
然后他决定马上逃跑 And he immediately began his escape.
接下来 在医院里 他认罪了 And then, in the hospital, he confessed.
不是因为错觉才招供 It wasn't a delusional confession.
他详细描述了他所犯下的罪行 He described a fact pattern which was completely consistent with the crime.
被告承认了他当时是因为害怕 The defendant admitted that he was afraid of yet
再次被定贩毒罪 从而被判终生监禁 another drug conviction that would land him a life sentence.
他慌了 掏出枪 开火 He panicked, pulled out a gun, and fired.
而现在他的辩护律师说 Now his lawyer suggests
也许他在供认时 产生了错觉 he was perhaps delusional when he confessed,
或者他只是想保护一个朋友 一个爱人 而撒谎顶罪 or that he simply lied to protect the real killer, a friend or loved one.
绝望之人的垂死狡辩 Desperate suggestions for a desperate client.
这侮辱了法庭 还有你们 It's insulting to this court, to you,
尤其是侮辱了那位女士和她的2个孩子 and especially to that woman and her two children.
Warren Litch谋杀了她的丈夫 Warren Litch murdered her husband.
Warren Litch杀害了他们的父亲 Warren Litch killed their father.
他已经向警察供认了罪行 He admitted to the police that he did so.
没必要再浪费时间了 Let's not waste any more time.
Edwin Edwin.
该你了 It's your turn.
我昨晚睡着了 忘了准备结案陈词 I fell asleep last night and forgot to prepare a closing.
我本来想告诉你的 I meant to tell you.
你没有结案陈词 You don't have a closing
没有 你有吗 No, do you
辩方 Counsel
Edwin 你什么都没准备 Edwin, you've got nothing
当我还是个孩子时 我父亲对我说过 When I was a little boy, my father said to me.
我现在依然记得 他肯定是说 I can still hear his voice. I believe he said,
女士优先 Ladies first.
我不知道你们怎么看 I don't know about you,
但是如果我听说某人承认犯罪了 but if I hear that somebody confessed to a crime,
我会认为他是真的有罪 I just assume he's guilty.
但是如果我知道他是被迫的 那么 But if I hear the confession is coerced, then
比如说 for example,
一个腹部伤口流血不止的人 you could have a man bleeding out with a stomach wound,
被一屋子的警察和牧师 put him in a room with police and clergy
坚持指认他做了某件事 who keep insisting to him that he did something,
也许他就会信以为真 and he might actually come to believe it.
如果他的好友或亲人 And gee, what if it was a friend or a loved one
刚好那天晚上开了Warren的车 who was driving Warren's car that night
那就能解释为什么Warren会想要逃了 不是吗 That would explain why Warren was trying to flee, wouldn't it
他能预感地到警察会错误地逮捕他 He likely knew the police were coming to mistakenly arrest him.
警察调查过这些吗 Did the police investigate any of this
上帝 我们全都认为Warren litch有罪 My god, we all assume Warren litch is guilty,
但是如果他没有呢 but what if he isn't
现在我们再来看看其他证据 Now let's turn to the other evidence.
等等 Wait
没有其他证据 There is no other evidence.
没有枪 没有目击证人 没有纤维 没有法医鉴定 No gun, no witnesses, no fibers, no forensics.
有的只是一份被迫做出的供词 All they have is that coerced confession.
你们可能认为是他做的 Now, you might think he did it.
甚至认为这是理所当然的 And if you're determined, you can even still assume it, I suppose.
但是如果你相信法律 But if you're to uphold the law and
要求用证据以排除所有合理疑点 demand proof beyond all reasonable doubt,
当我们放弃这种要求时 and if we don't demand that,
我们真的希望对警察说 do we really wanna send a message to the police
嘿 去它的证据 Hey, forget the evidence.
只要口供就好 Just bring us that confession.
他们真应该给你一个专用办公室 They really should give you your own office.
显然 那个商场职员翻供了 Evidently, the store clerk has recanted.
他突然间又不确定是否真的看见 Lee Tyler偷那条围巾了 He's suddenly not sure he saw Lee Tyler take the scarf.
案子就这么结了 这真是个伟大的国家 The case might even be dropped. It's a great country.
地方检查官已经投诉你了 The district attorney has lodged a complaint against you
罪名是干扰 恐吓证人 妨碍司法公正 还有勒索 for witness tampering, intimidation, obstruction of justice, extortion.
他应该挑出重点 He should make up his mind.
这间公司不会参与那些行为 律师 This firm does not engage in that kind of conduct, counsel.
我们绝不会恐吓或勒索 We do not intimidate or blackmail.
Crane Poole & Schmidt律师行的律师 The attorney sat Crane, Poole & Schmidt
行事总是诚实而又光明磊落的 conduct themselves with integrity always.
我说得够明白吗 Do I make myself clear
非常明白 More than clear.
清晰透彻 Transparent.
走吧 Go.
Shore先生 Mr. Shore,
谢谢你 thank you.
陪审团主席 陪审团已经做出一致裁定了吗 Madam Foreperson, the jury has reached a unanimous verdict
是的 法官大人 We have, your honor.
Litch先生 请起立 Mr. Litch, please rise.
陪审团主席 你们的裁决是 Madam Foreperson, what say you
陪审团决定 We the jury,
Massachusetts州诉Warren Litch一案 in the matter of the commonwealth of Massachusetts versus Warren Litch,
一级谋杀的指控 on the charge of first-degree murder,
裁定被告Warren Litch 有罪 we find the defendant Warren Litch guilty.
陪审团的各位成员 感谢你们为本案做出的努力 Members of the jury, I would like to thank you for your service in this matter.
你们可以解散了 You are hereby excused.
请到法庭代表处签出 Please be sure to sign out with the courtroom deputy
以便记录你们已履行义务 so you are credited for your time here.
被告在判决前将被移交回县里 The defendant is to be retained in county until sentencing,
判决将在60天内做出 which shall be scheduled within 60 days' time.
如果没有异议 我们就此休庭 If that is all, then we are adjourned.
听着 呃 Listen, um,
我会尽一切可能帮你上诉的 I'll review any grounds for appeal.
那个供认 还有回旋余地 The confession, I mean, there are grounds.
好 好 Okay. Okay.
我会和你联络 我会申请案件记录抄本 I'll be in touch. I'll order up the transcript.
听着 呃 Listen, um,
我从你的感受想过 I thought for somebody who felt the way you felt,
你能尽力就是很可敬的了 it was honorable for you to try your hardest.
而我知道你已经尽力了 And I know that you did.
谢谢你 Thank you.
没有准备结案陈词是我的失职 Unprofessional for me not to be prepared with my closing.
我想我可能还得回医院去 I think I'll perhaps go back to the hospital,
稍微休整一下 get a little tune-up.
你应该感觉能看开点了 Surely you're feeling better about things.
我用酒精安抚了你 I've plied you with alcohol.
我很抱歉 I'm sorry.
我突然间想到 Alan It suddenly occurred to me, Alan,
你根本不是在利用我 you weren't using me at all.
你是在利用Miles You were using Miles.
怎么说 How so
我想 I think
他只是个被你利用的工具 好让我觉得你卑鄙 he was some sort of device for you to look despicable in my eyes.
你就是这么对付女人的 It's your pattern with women,
我想 就是让她们 I think, to get them to
你知道当你剖析我的内心世界时 You know when you psychoanalyze me,
我对你的欲望要少了很多 I find you much less sexually attractive.
是的 很好的转移了话题 但是 Yes, nice deflection, but
别想钻进我的脑袋 Sally Don't try and get in my head, Sally.
你不会喜欢那一团糟的 You won't like the mess.
那天晚上你不是要我离开律师这一行 You weren't telling me to run from the law the other night.
你是要我离开你 You were telling me to run from you.
也许你觉得我跟你交往 Maybe you think it's my relationship with you
会让我失去人性 that's ultimately dehumanizing.
所以作为一个不可思议的好人 So being an incredibly decent man,
就是你 无论你怎么去掩饰 which you are underneath all your stuff,
你决定警告我 you decided to warn me.
我不是想把你推开 I'm not trying to push you away.
那你想留住我 Are you trying to keep me
我们要么更进一步 要么后退 We either go forward or go in opposite direction,
因为我一点也不喜欢我们现在的关系 because I don't like where we are now.
更进一步 意思是 What forward do you mean
你知道吗 You know what
我想我可以先走一步了 I think I'll just move forward.