波士顿法律 前情提要 Previously on Boston legal
嫌疑犯于晚上10:30 被发现 Suspects were first observed at approximately 10:30 P.M.
在警察局对面 Across the street from the station house.
罗宾和猫女负责放哨 Robin and catwoman stood guard
而蝙蝠侠在擦洗一辆停着的警车 as batman soaped an unoccupied police vehicle.
是SUV 法官阁下 那种耗油吓死人的车 S.U.V., Your honor, an egregious gas guzzler.
而且还很脏 继续 警官 And filthy, by the way. Continue, officer.
Brody警官和我到达现场后 与他们发生了激烈争执 Officer Brody and I approached. An altercation ensued.
我们以为他们只是穿着剧服的流氓 We thought they were hooligans dressed in costume.
或着是一群乡巴佬 As the village people, perhaps.
嫌犯拒捕 These suspects then attempted to evade apprehension
并向我们扔了许多鸡蛋 by discharging one or more eggs in our direction.
对他们的指控包括恶意破坏 拒捕 拉皮条 The charges are vandalism, resisting arrest, and pandering.
拉皮条 Pandering
我们所作所为 完全出于应激反应 Our only tricks were in conjunction with our treating,
而且我哪像拉皮条的 and I do not look like a pimp.
你像白痴 You look like an idiot.
法官大人 这只猫是个有名的妓女 我反对 The cat's a known prostitute, your honor.I object to that
好了 取下面具 All right, masks off now.
我知道你 I know you.
Alan Shore Alan Shore.
法官大人 很高兴见到你 Good to see you, judge.
这是我的同事 Tara Wilson My colleague Tara Wilson.
你好 Hello.
能告诉我为什么 Would you care to explain to me
两个律师和一个妓女搞在一起 why two attorneys are outcavorting with a prostitute
我们需要人扮演猫女 We needed somebody to be catwoman.
拿着皮鞭的那种 Someone with a whip.
Mr.Shore 你是一个有天赋的律师 Mr. Shore, while you are a gifted attorney,
可你也让整个法律界蒙羞 you bring embarrassment and shame to the legal community.
谢谢你这么说 阁下 You're very kind, sir.
案件撤销 Case dismissed.
跟Markham协议怎么样了 What's this with the Markham settlement
他拒绝签字 He refuses to sign.
不停在字眼里挑刺 He keeps redlining us on language.
估计因为税收问题 他想拖到下一年 We think that he's postponing it until after the new year for tax reasons.
我会尽力施加压力 I'll keep pushing him as best I can.
说点私事 我想提醒大家记得投票 On a personal aside, I'd like to remind everyone to vote.
不管政见如何 都是我们的公民义务 It's our civic duty. Whatever our politics,
哪怕是世界末日 我们还是美国人 at the end of the day, we're Americans.
就算流血 也要是蓝白红色的 We bleed red, white, and blue.
Morgan对Rayburn的案子 Morgan vs. Rayburn.
还在审理中 Still in trial.
这个客户的证词不可靠 The client survived his testimony barely.
Tara和我正想办法达成协议 也说点私事 Tara and I are pushing a settlement, and on a personal aside,
我觉得无聊 什么 I'm bored. I beg your pardon
你们老给我些无聊案子 You people keep assigning me these boring cases.
要在从前 我的委托人里有杀人的 At my old firm, I got murderers.
还有在公共洗手间自慰的 I had clients who had touched themselves in public restrooms.
这些人才是真正的客户 These are people you could root for,
说不定还能来段罗曼史 not to mention relate to.
Mr.Shore 莫非你想另某高就 Is there some other place you'd rather be, Mr. Shore
是的 我想上电视 Yes, I want to be on cable.
最棒的案子都在那里 That's where all the best work is being done.
Holcomb的案子谁在做 呃 Edwin Poole Who's doing the Holcomb case Uh, that's Edwin Poole.
不是你 我只是负责处理些小事 Aren't you I just handled the decert motion.
不负责庭审的 I didn't prep the trial.
当然 那Edwin把案子分配给谁了 Surely, Edwin assigned it to somebody
这个 Well, um
其实 actually
Denny Denny
你在负责Holcomb药品案 Are you handling the Holcomb pharmaceuticals trial
是我 I am.
你准备好了 Are you prepared to try this case
我会的 I will be.
你会的 你知不知道明天就要开审了 You will be. Are you aware the trial begins tomorrow
Lori 我们有麻烦了 We have a problem, Lori.
你至少得给我看着点Denny You at least need to backstop Denny here.
我没.. 可我不能 I don't I can't.
今天我就有案子要上庭 I'm in trial myself today.
什么案子 In trial on what
我..嗯..我几天前接了个法庭指派的案子 I, um, was assigned a case a couple of days ago,
至少我是接下来了.. which I sort of took.
什么样的 What kind of case
这个..只是个.. Uh, just a
凶杀案 homicide.
什么 What
你怎么突然开始接受法庭指派了 Why are you suddenly taking court appointments
我只是需要点改变 I just need kind of a change, that's all.
现在所有人都不满意了 这算什么 Now everyone here is dissatisfied What is this
上周我处理的案子 The case I did last week
它某种程度上让我想明白了一些事 it kind of awakened me a little.
我想要和人有更多的相处 I'm feeling the need to connect with people.
是犯罪的人吧 请不要那么浅薄 Criminal people. Please don't trivialize this.
辩护与起诉相差很多 Lori Criminal defense is a far cry from criminal prosecution, Lori.
你不会喜欢的 You won't like it.
你怎么会知道 我还没 How can you possibly know that before I even
我了解你 I know you.
那么.. So
我们可以开始了 Shall we
当然 你有Morgan的地址吗 We shall. Do you have Morgan's address
我有 但其实我想说 I do, but what I meant is,
我们从昨晚中断的地方继续吧 shall we continue where we left off last night
你在我房子前面 朝着植物撒尿 In front of my building with you peeing in the planter.
我差点就爆了 你应该让我上楼的 I was about to burst. You should've let me come up.
那些植物需要浇水了 That plant needed watering.
Tara 你应该让我上去的 You should've let me come up, Tara.
零晨四点 我让你上来了 It was 4:00 A.M. I let you up,
接着能记得的 就是我们在酒吧 next thing we know, we're in the liquor cabinet.
2分钟后后 就什么也不知道了 Two minutes after that, passed out.
Robin四仰八叉缠在蝙蚨侠身上 Robin sprawled across batman.
在司法厅他们会怎么说 What would they say at the hall of justice
这就是你担心的 四仰八叉 Was that what you were afraid of, the sprawling
我叫你出来玩 是想让你忘记Sally I invited you out to get your mind off Sally.
你是做到了 我又是那个你熟悉的荒唐的人了 You've succeeded. It's back to an old, familiar wanton place.
Alan 我们说好了 我们不可能 Alan, we agreed that you and I couldn't work.
是为什么来着 我忘记了 What was the reason again I've forgotten.
因为会惹麻烦 It would be trouble.
只是一晚 我们就完全失控 然后倒在酒吧后面 One night out, we lose all control Which was utterly intoxicating, and end up behind bars.
回味无穷不是吗 一起疯狂 was it not, losing control together
怎样 Tara What about it, Tara
都这么久了 我们或许应该开始脱光.. After all this time, maybe we should undress.
我们要迟到了 We're late.
很厚的文件 Thick file.
当然很厚 Of course, it's a thick file.
这是上千人共同起诉的案子 It's a class action involving thousands of plaintiffs,
而且错综复杂 Denny and it's complicated, Denny.
很厚 Thick file.
你看 我们唯一能做的 就是请求法官的谅解 Look, all we can do is throw ourselves at the mercy of the judge.
你跟我去见法官 解释下Edwin的状况 If you and I both go to see him and explained Edwin's situation,
或许能争取到一些时间 maybe he'll give us some time.
厚啊 Thick file.
7万美元 $70,000.
这是他们开的价 It's their opening offer.
Mr.Morgan 你是个好人 You seem like a very nice man, Mr. Morgan.
可也像个忧郁症患者 You also seem like a hypochondriac.
我是真的头疼 These headaches are real.
我相信 I have no doubt.
你曾经还抱怨过 You've also complained on several occasions
你感染了塔那痘病毒 that you were suffering from tanapox virus.
我发现皮肤上有典型的泡疹 Because I noticed the characteristic papular lesions.
它们非常容易破掉 They're very tender.
直径大约2厘米 Approximately 2 centimeters in diameter.
你要知道塔那痘病毒 是非洲靠近赤道附近的地方病 You realize the tanapox virus is endemic to equatorial Africa.
是的 你去了那么多次 旅途愉快吗 Yes.Have you enjoyed your many visits to equatorial Africa
我从来没去过 I've never been there.
呃 这样的话 Ah. Then perhaps
你应该可以看出 我们的麻烦所在了吧 Mr.Morgan you can see the outline of our problem, Mr. Morgan.
可这不是我的错 Look, it's not my fault.
我去图书馆 I go to the library,
查资料 and I read books.
我想知道 怎样才能好起来 And I try to understand how I might get better,
可有时侯书里的内容 反而让我更害怕了 but sometimes, the books, they scare me even more
他们总是能描述出那些连我自己 都不知道已经得了的病 because they describe diseases I didn't even know I had.
大概我是有忧郁症 Maybe I am a hypochondriac.
你怎么想 What do you take for that
Colson小姐 我之前从来没有打过架 Miss Colson, I have never been in a fight before.
这样 我们要找一两个证人 Okay, we need to be able to call a witness or two
谁能来证明你并不暴力 who can speak to your nonviolent character.
我妈妈可以 Well, I told you, my mother.
母亲有偏袒嫌疑 最好不要 Mothers tend to come off as biased.
应该还有其他人的 There's gotta be somebody else.
朋友 同事 一定还有 Friends, coworkers. There's gotta be somebody.
可我在家住 在家工作 我几乎不出门的 Well, I live at home, I work at home, I hardly ever go out.
我妈妈是唯一能 My mother's the only one
但我要提前警告你 but I gotta warn you,
她的形象不是很好 she doesn't make the best impression.
什么意思 What do you mean
她有一个玻璃假眼 Well, she's got a glass eye.
尺寸不太合适 所以她一激动 And it doesn't fit so good, and when she gets upset
如果你让她出庭作证 if you put her on the stand,
不要惹她发怒 don't get her upset.
我去吧台拿些喝的 I went up to the bar to get a few drinks,
我转过身就看到 唔 and when I turned around, that's when I saw, uh,
Jared和他在吵架 Jared and him exchanging words.
我看得出他们言词不善 And I could tell it wasn't friendly.
他 By him
就是被告 The defendant.
我开始往回走 那里非常拥挤 So I started heading back, and the place was really packed.
我被堵住了 So I was kinda blocked.
那时看到Jared在推他 That's when I saw Jared push him,
然后Jared挥了一拳 然后 and then Jared took a swing, and
就这样了 That was it.
什么样了 What was it
告诉我们你所看到的 Tell us what you saw.
被告就朝Jared喉咙猛击了一下 The defendant, he just threw a punch right at Jared's throat,
Jared就瘫倒在地了 and Jared collapsed to the ground.
我赶到那时 When I got there,
他呼吸很困难 而且 he was hardly breathing, and
他嘴里不断发出倒抽气的声音 he was making, like, a sucking noise.
最后他停止了呼吸 And then he just stopped breathing.
我试过人工呼吸 And I tried to do mouth-to-mouth,
有个说会CPR的人也尝试了 可他 and so did another guy who said he knew CPR, but he
他只是躺在那里 死了 He just died right there on the floor.
好的 Okay.
Quinlan先生 这很关键 Now, Mr. Quinlan, this is important.
尽可能的详细描述那一个猛击 Describe the punch as best you can.
很短促 直接的击打 我可以 It was a short, direct punch, and I could .
我可以从他握拳的姿势 and I could tell by the way he was holding his hand
和他出拳样子 知道他会武术 and how he threw the punch that he knew martial arts.
那是致命的一击 It was a kill punch.
反对 反对有效 Objection Sustained.
根据你的说法 为什么你会认为那是致命的一击 Why, in your lay opinion, sir, did you regard it as a kill punch
反对 反对驳回 Objection.Overruled.
他可以回答 He can answer.
攻击对方的喉咙 会导致喉部的衰竭 By hitting the throat, you can make it collapse,
受击打者就会窒息 and then the person suffocates.
就像已经发生的那样 Which is exactly what happened.
谢谢 Okay.
你并没有看到争吵的开始 You didn't actually see the altercation begin.
你只是转过身 看到他们正在说话 You turned around, and they were having words.
是的 你听不到他们在说什么 That's right. You couldn't hear what was said
是的 Mr.Quinlan 警察在现场做笔录时 No.Mr. Quinlan, when the police arrived and questioned you,
你有否说过我委托人的那一拳 did you tell them that you recognized my client's punch
是武术里的一种拳法 as a form of martial arts
没有 我不肯定 No, I was probably
你有否对警方描述了那一拳 就像你刚才对陪审团说的那样 Did you demonstrate to them the fist you just made for the jury
我当时太震惊了 I was too shook up.
事实上你从未提到过武术二字 In fact, you made no mention of martial arts
直到这两个字被印上了报纸 until after it was published in the newspapers.
当我读到的时候 这两个字提醒了我 And when I read it, it clicked.
它很恰当 就像我所看到的那样 It all made perfect sense, because that's what I saw.
所以当你面对警方详细询的时候 You just forgot to mention it
你只是忘记提到了那一拳 when the police specifically asked you what you saw.
请问那晚你喝了多少啤酒 How many beers had you had that night, sir
3瓶 Jared Grant喝了多少 Three.How many beers had Jared Grant had
3瓶 所以 你承认没有听到他们的争吵 Three.So you admittedly couldn't hear the exchange,
也承认没看到争执的开始 you admittedly didn't see the altercation begin,
而且你还喝了酒 and you'd been drinking.
没有人能预计Edwin Poole的病 Certainly no one could anticipate Edwin Poole's illness.
这个病几周前就发作了 This unanticipated illness occurred weeks ago.
你们在庭审前一天才来找我 You come to me the day before the trial
实际上这是我们的工作疏忽 The simple truth is, this one fell through the cracks.
起诉方的证人有些是从城外赶来的 The plaintiff has witnesses from out of town.
我们非常乐意补偿这些损失 We'd be willing to assume those costs.
天啊 多么自大的一群人 Gee, what a swell bunch of guys.
法官阁下 哦不 不 不 我最讨厌这样的 Your honor oh, no, no, no, I'm sick of this.
你们在用拖延策略 Your firm has employed a strategy systemic heel-dragging.
这不符职业道德 Edwin poole是唯一一个知道 It is immoral.Edwin poole is the only one who know
这是谁的错 Whose fault is that
你们自己玩忽职守 You people should be sued for malpractice.
Brian 你和我有交情 Brian, you and I have a relationship.
我把你当朋友 I think of you as a friend.
不过交情排在原则的后面 抱歉 Well, that friendship has gotta take a back seat to principle, I'm sorry.
Brian 你知道 考虑到我们的关系 Well, you know, Brian, given our relationship,
我觉得当友谊陷入困境时 我应该坦诚相待 I feel entitled to be honest the way friends are during difficult times.
我能对你坦诚吗 Brian Can I be honest with you, Brian
请说 Denny Please. Denny
你是个混蛋 还是个贪婪的混蛋 You're a bastard, and a greedy one at that.
这是件共同起诉案 This is a class action.
合并审判 一下解决这么多案子让你大受赞赏 You get credit for all the consolidated cases in one fell swoop.
你正在谋求首席法官的位置 You're looking to make presiding judge.
所以年终你更需要建功立业 You need that credit by calendar year's end.
所以你急切的要案子进行 来装饰你的诉讼记录 That's why you're desperate to move this thing forward, to pad your docket.
这是野心 不是道德 你是个贪婪的流着鼻涕的小人 This is about ambition, not morality, you greedy, sniveling little wop.
延期申请不通过 Motion for continuance denied.
你知道我要怎么做吗 Brian You know what I'm gonna do, Brian,
为了证明我俩没伤到和气 just to show you there are no hard feelings
我要和你的妻子上床 I'm gonna sleep with your wife.
我们建议要么你解雇我们 It is our recommendation that you discharge us as counsel.
向法官请求时间找新律师 Ask the judge for time to find new attorneys.
或者明天照常继续 The only alternative is proceeding tomorrow,
我估计没人这样希望 which I don't think we want to do.
Edwin Poole从来没有告诉我们 审理的日期 Edwin Poole never even gave us this trial date.
他说还没确定 He told us it was continued indefinitely.
所以我们建议你解雇我们 Which is why we're suggesting that you discharge us.
法官必须给你时间找新律师 He has got to give you time to find new counsel.
Sally 这次必须你来 我 You have to handle this, Sally. Me
瞧 我对玻璃眼球有心理障碍 Look, I have this thing about glass eyes.
我有个老师也这样 I once had a teacher with a glass eye,
有时候他一激动起来 and sometimes when he'd get mad,
就拿出来往桌子上拍 he'd take it out and whack it on his desk.
简直是恶梦 It gave me nightmares.
嗨 Hi, there.
嘿 Hey.
她怎么了 What was that
没什么 Nothing.
看上去有人急切的渴望 Someone just seems a little overeager
和Alan Shore旧情复燃 to rekindle the flame with Alan Shore.
我们坚持7万美元 The offer was firm at $70,000.
是的 可如果不那么坚持 你们多提高1/4 我们就接受了 Yes, we thought if you'd un-firm it to one and a quater, we could be done.
而你的委托人 明天就不用上庭 Your client wouldn't have to testify tomorrow,
当然他就能更多的误诊其他人了 which, of course, would free him up to misdiagnose others.
看来你还没明白 Mr. Shore. You don't seem to get it, Mr. Shore.
给7万美元 我们只是要摆脱无赖纠缠 We offered $70,000 as nuisance change.
是的 我们只是觉得 Mr. Morgan Yes. We just feel Mr. Morgan
要比你说的更令人无赖 is a much bigger nuisance than you give him credit for.
而我更是无比的无赖 我们应该可以为此再多拿点 And I'm an enormous nuisance. We should get something for that.
我想吐 你会没事的 I feel nauseous. You'll be fine.
敲门 Knock on it.
你来 Sally You knock on it.Sally
如果是我负责与她对话 至少你来敲门 If I'm doing the talking, the least you could do is
律师 You, his lawyers
嗨 嗨 Hi.Hi.
我是Sally Heep 这位是 I'm Sally Heep. This is
你好 Lori Colson Lori Colson. Hello.
嗯 我们想问几个问题 Binder夫人 如果可以的话 Uh, we just wanted to ask you a few questions, Mrs. Binder, if we could.
进来 Come on in.
他是个心地善良的好男孩 He's a wonderful boy with a gentle heart.
是的 我们的问题是 Yes, our problem is,
你似乎是唯一一个了解他的人 you seem to be the only person to truly know him.
他觉得因为这个假眼 我不会是个好证人 He think I'll make a bad witness on account of the eye.
它是玻璃的 看到了吗 It's glass, you see.
近些看 Look close.
是的 Yes.
嗯 Yeah.
事情是这样的 The thing is,
检控方宣称 the prosecution is obviously claiming
Jason的心地并不善良 that Jason's heart is not gentle.
他和人有过纠纷吗 Has he ever been in trouble
他曾经被拘捕过吗 Has he ever been arrested
他替其他人惹过麻烦吗 Has he ever caused any problems for anybody
没有 他是个好人 我也是这么教他的 No, he is a nice young man, and it's the way I raised him.
这就是我们希望你说的 That's exactly what we'll need you to say.
也许我可以带你去买点衣服 做个头发 I'm also maybe gonna take you shopping, get your hair done.
形象越好 Jared Grant 他该死 The more presentable He deserved to die, Jared Grant.
为什么这么说 Why do you say that
他打了我的 Jason. He beat up my Jason.
不过 他没有打得很厉害 Well, he didn't exactly beat him up.
只是发生了口角 他痛打了他 There was an altercation. He beat him up.
那个男的是恶魔 他该死 The man is evil, and he deserved to die
冷静下来 我告诉你了 他该死 Let's calm down. He deserved it, I tell you
Rayburn医生 Dr. Rayburn,
Mr. Morgan 由你来负责超过6个月了 over the six months that Mr. Morgan was in your care,
他来过你这多少次 how many visits did he make to your practice
38次 38.
算多吗 Is that a lot
比其他病人多出四倍 Four times as many as any other patient.
我们玩笑说他是办公室的吉祥物 We joked he was the office mascot.
你说的出病状 他就坚信自己得了那些病 You name the condition Mr. Morgan was convinced he had it.
伤风 感冒 支气管炎 Cold, flu, bronchitis,
带状疱疹 成人发作性糖尿病 shingles, adult onset diabetes.
我从来没说过糖尿病 I never complained of adult onset diabetes.
那个的症状应该是口渴 That's characterized by excessive thirst.
你觉得我今天喝了很多水 Does it seem to you like I've been drinking a lot today
我确定你很好 Bill I'm sure you're fine, Bill.
Mr. Morgan 认为你的疏忽 导致了他今天的状况 Mr. Morgan contends your neglect drove him to this state.
实际上 我已经尽量的容忍他了 The truth is, I bent over backwards to accommodate him.
他总要求立刻见我 He always needed to be seen immediately,
无论我有多忙 and busy as my practice is,
我总是挤出时间 I always made the time.
我为你感到骄傲 先生 为你不知疲倦的对待我的委托人 I applaud you, sir, for your tireless commitment to my client.
多好的人 What a guy
反对 反对有效 Objection.Sustained.
所以这38次 都算在诊所头上 G So these 38 visits, on the house
什么 I'm sorry
它们都是免费的 They were free visits
不是 No.
哦 Oh
所以你是收了钱的 这就合理了 So you charged him. That makes sense.
所以当他抱怨浑身无力 So with all his complaining, his incapacitation,
痛苦的脸皱成一团 that pinched look on his face,
其实一点毛病没有 there's nothing wrong with him.
临床上没有 而问题出在他脑袋里了 Nothing clinically, no. It's in his head.
只是普通的偏头痛 对吗 Traditional home for the migraine, is it not
是心身失调 It's psychosomatic.
他是个典型的抑郁症患者 He's a classic hypochondriac.
我明白了 I see.
所以 还是有个诊断的 Well, there's a diagnosis.
那么告诉我 你开出了什么处方 Tell me, what treatment did you prescribe
医治我委托人的典型的抑郁症 for my client's classic hypochondria
我是全科医生 不是精神病学医师 I'm a general practitioner, not a psychiatrist.
所以你建议他出去找 So you referred him out to
谁 whom
没有特定的谁 No one in particular.
我告诉了他 他需要帮助 I did tell him he needed help.
我甚至给了他一个从业者的名单 I believe I even gave him a list of practitioners.
所以当他仍然来看病 So he kept coming to you,
你只是继续收钱 却不治疗 you kept taking his money, you did not treat him,
而且还建议他去看 and you referred him to
一个不确定的医生 no one in particular.
我是全科医生 I'm a G.P.
我告诉他 要进行精神治疗 I told him to seek mental treatment.
我只是建议 我不能强迫他 I advised it. I can't force it.
所以我们再总结一次 他不停的来 你不停的收钱 Once again, he kept coming, you kept taking the money,
然后建议他去看一个 and you referred him to
不确定的医生 no one in particular.
那么你要解雇你的律师 So you now want to fire your lawyers
是的 法官阁下 Yes, your honor.
我们不知道审理什么时候开始 We had no idea trial was about to start.
足以说明他们有多不合格 That's how incompetent these people are.
我估计你也没意识到 And I suppose you had no idea
你的公司正欺诈着老年人 your company was bilking senior citizens
当然阁下你也一定是开明的 因为.. Certainly your honor intends to keep an open mind with regard to the
就这么决定了 Here's the deal.
我可以给你一天找律师 24个小时 I give you one day to find new counsel, 24 hours.
这以后 我会对你们的拖延 罚以每天25万美元 After that, I'm fining you $250,000 a day for any further delay.
这看上去像公报私仇 It almost seemed personal.
你们做过什么招惹这家伙没 Have you done anything to upset this guy
我不记得有过 Not that I can think of.
看 撇开准备这事不谈 Well, look, aside from preparation concerns,
我们有更大的问题了 we got a bigger problem.
这个法官 他有偏见 This judge, he's biased.
所以我想建议 This is what I propose we do.
我们起草一份和谈申请 要求 那是25万美元一天 File an interlocutory appeal and ask At $250,000 a day.
要求和谈 我们就有路可走了 While we're filing that appeal, we'll go forward.
如果赢了 我们就能搁置审判 Should we win, we can suspend the trial.
输了 也不会被罚款 Should we lose, we won't incur the fine.
你的人能搞定这个吗 But are you people ready to try this case
我来 I can try it.
Denny Crane Denny Crane.
有几个谈判都被搁置了 There were some settlement discussions that broke down.
如果Denny开局不错 他们应该会回到谈判桌前 If Denny can open big, that might bring them back to the table,
这也是目前唯一的办法 which may be the best way to go at this point.
是四年前在Brighton的一个公园 It was four years ago at a park in Brighton.
你遇到了被告 You met the defendant.
这个 不能算是遇到 Well, I didn't exactly meet him.
那是什么 Well, what then
我海扁了他一顿 I beat the crap out of him.
抱歉 Excuse me.
我已经改过自新了 I was a different person then.
好的 Mr. Stone 请详细告诉我们 那时发生了什么 Okay, Mr. Stone, we need to be very specific about what happened back then.
当时他想跟我们一起打篮球 Well, he tried to get into a game of pickup hoops.
我和一个兄弟就骂了他几句 Me and another guy in the game we started dissing him a little.
他回了嘴 He said something back,
我们就狠揍了他一顿 and we beat him up pretty good.
当然我并不引以为傲 I'm not proud of it.
你确定那是 Jason Binder And you're sure it was Jason Binder.
是的 Yeah,
看到报纸上的照片 我记得他的脸 when I saw his picture on the news, I remembered his face.
绝对是他 It was definitely him.
那另一个打他的人呢 And what about the other guy who beat him up
Jared Grant 就是他杀的那个 Jared Grant, the guy he killed.
你骗了我 You lied to me.
在打架前你就 Not only were you in a fight before
这不代表什么 it doesn't prove anything.
他们有你杀人的动机了 Jason Now they have a motive, Jason.
被害人四年前打了你 然后你就开始练习跆拳道 The victim beats you up four years ago, you take up Taekwondo,
这么巧你又遇到了他 you just so happen to encounter him,
于是就杀了他 at which point you kill him
不是你说的那样 It wasn't like that.
这就是为什么你妈妈会说他该死 因为 That's why your mom said he deserved to die, because
不是那样的 It wasn't like that.
我还能去辩护什么 What am I supposed to argue now
坦白讲 Jason 是为了报仇 你才去酒吧的吗 Let's have it, Jason. Did you go to that bar to get revenge
我是去让自己面对他 I went there to stand up to him.
你无法想象 我受着怎样的煎熬 被他们 You have no idea how haunted I was by
四年前 我连手都没敢举起来过 I didn't even put up my hands four years ago.
不是挨打在折磨我 It wasn't getting beat up that stuck with me.
是我根本没 It was that I didn't even
我只是任由自己挨打 I just let myself get beat up.
所以你开始练习武术 So you took up martial arts.
然后我去了那里找他 And I went there to stand up to him.
我没有想要打架 I didn't plan to fight.
更没想过杀他 I certainly didn't go there to kill him.
当他一拳挥来 我只是 Then when he swung at me, I just
反击了 I swung back.
我没有想杀他 I never meant to kill him.
我们多收了谁的钱 Who are we overbilling
医疗保险还是那些老人们 medicare or senior citizens
都有 但医疗保险没有起诉我们 Both, but medicare isn't suing us.
我们是指制药公司 Us. Meaning the drug company.
是的 但如果是医院在滥收费 Correct.But if the hospitals are doing the overcharging,
那帮老年人干吗要告制药公司 why are the seniors suing the drug company
Denny 我们已经讨论这个问题了 Denny, we've been over this before.
制药公司 也就是我们的委托人 跟医院有私下协议 The drug company, our client, has the sweetheart deals with the hospitals.
我们给医院回扣 医院则虚高药的成本价 We give them rebates so they disguise the real cost of the drugs.
向医疗保险开出高于原价的帐单 相当于滥计成本 They then bill medicare for the higher, allegedly inflated costs.
真的 这我们要怎么辩 Really. What's our defense to that
7万5千美元 你们只提高了5千块 $75,000. You've upped your offer by $5,000.
已经相当慷慨了 We feel it's generous,
尤其是你的委托人没有实质性的伤害 particularly when your client's injuries aren't real.
那些病是真的 好了 Bill They're real. All right, Bill.
你要知道 Mr. Morgan 我不是那种挑拨离间的律师 You know, Mr. Morgan, I don't typically counsel opposing parties,
但我建议你起诉你的律师失职 but I might advise a legal malpractice claim against the attorney
就是那个灌输你百万发财梦的律师 who filled your head with million-dollar windfalls.
你那里好像有点什么 You seem to have a little something wedged
第4 第5之间 between numbers four and five.
估计本来就长在你嘴里 I guess it's just part of your mouth.
最后说一次 能接受的 One last proposal that's entirely possible
当然算不算玩笑取决于你的反应 I'm kidding, by the way, depending upon your reaction,
30万 成交 $300,000, sealed.
私下我们退还你5万 We kick back $50,000 to you under the table.
Mr. Shore 我向你保证 我不是那种律师 Mr. Shore, I guarantee you, I am not that kind of attorney.
真的 Really.
上帝 我是 Gosh, I am.
我要直接向律师协会举报你 I should report you directly to the bar,
或者是向检查官 if not the district attorney.
如果你这么想 那我就是在开玩笑 Well, if that's how you feel, then I was kidding.
我要去法官那了 I'm going to the judge now.
太棒了 一场诉讼 Excellent. New trial.
你委托人的花费一定要超过7万5了 That'll certainly cost your client much more than $75,000.
你的提议不被接受 Your offer is rejected.
万一他去法官那 Suppose he does, go to the judge.
拜托 他可不想弄个无效审判 他觉得稳操胜券了 Oh, please, he doesn't want a mistrial. He thinks he's won.
再说他没法证明我不是开玩笑 Plus, he can't prove I wasn't kidding.
我有名的搞笑 I'm known to be funny.
这是个连蚊子都不杀的孩子 This is a child who wouldn't slap a mosquito.
他只是挥走它们 He would shoo it away.
他甚至不能容忍自己去伤害 一只苍蝇或是任何动物 He couldn't bring himself to harm a fly or any animal,
更何况是人 certainly not a human being.
四年心怀怨恨 你不认为他会爆发 Four years harboring a grudge doesn't suggest a rage to you
他总被人欺负 Mr. Martin He was bullied by many people, Mr. Martin,
不仅仅是Jared Grant. 但他杀了Jared Grant. not just Jared Grant. But he killed Jared Grant.
他只是被迫去打架 He got into a fight,
而结果是个不幸的悲剧 which had a tragic ending.
他从没意图去谋杀 他也不能 He never intended to kill, nor could he.
他掌握了具有杀伤力的武术 Well, he learns a lethal martial arts maneuver that
他是为了自卫而学 He learned to defend himself.
瞧他的个子 看在上帝的份上 Look at the size of him, for god's sake.
他能怎么做 用智取来保护自己 What was he to do, defend people off with a sharp wit
Mrs. Binder 你很爱你的儿子对吗 Mrs. Binder, you love your son very much, don't you
当然 Of course I do.
事实上 他是你唯一的孩子 In fact, he's your only child.
他是你的一切 对吗 He's all you have, isn't he
是的 他和你一起住 Yes.He lives with you,
至少在被捕以前 or did before his arrest.
有什么问题吗 There's something wrong with that
我敢说你会做任何事 说任何话 只要他不进监狱 I bet you would do or say anything to keep him from going to prison.
我所说的全是实话 I'm up here telling the truth.
不 你在说谎 你只想让心爱的儿子 逃脱终身监禁的惩罚 No, you're telling lies to spare a loved one a life sentence.
不是 你才是说谎的人 No, you're the one at's telling lies.
你满口谎言 你的儿子是凶手 You're the liar here. Your son's a killer
不 他不是 你的儿子是杀人犯 No, he is not Your son is a killer.
不 他不是 No, he is not
这和橡胶手套又扯上什么关系了 What does a rubber glove have to do with this
Denny 那个所谓的欺诈控诉 不仅涉及处方药物 Denny, the alleged fraud goes beyond just prescription drugs.
也包括其他医疗物资 It goes to medical supplies as well.
看到橡胶手套 I see a rubber glove,
就让我想起别的 I'm heading in the other direction, I'll tell you that.
Denny 你究竟明不明白这个案子 Denny, do you understand what this case is about
完全明白 Paul I do, Paul.
那简单的给我们说一遍 Can you succinctly tell us
原告觉得自己在药物 和医疗物资上被骗了钱 The plaintiff thinks he's getting bilked for drugs and supplies.
其证据是 我们收取医院及门诊 的费用低于标价 His evidence is, we charged hospitals and clinics less for those very drugs and supplies.
我们的观点是 对客户的这种小小优惠 Our argument is, the mere offering of a discount to a consumer
不能算是对他人的超额收费 does not constitute the overbilling to another.
事实上 医院门诊及急诊室 In fact, since hospitals and clinics with ERs
经常治疗一些无支付能力的病人 regularly treat those who cannot pay,
所以我们认为 An argument could be made
我们的优惠被用在了 最需要帮助的病人身上 that we are extending these discounts to those most in need.
我们是在拯救生命 该死的 We're saving lives, damn it,
所以我非但不会为委托人的 这种行为感到不妥 and I will not apologize for my client's billing practices.
我要向他们致敬 也请你向他们致敬 I salute them. I invite you to salute them.
很好 Okay.
现在开始对委托人和医院进行垂直整合 Let's turn to the vertical integration between our clients and the hospitals.
你说啥 What the hell is that
Earl grey Earl grey, huh
它能让我清醒到周三 That would keep me up till Thursday.
能有几个小时就够了 Hopefully a few hours, at least.
你和Alan要开夜车 You and Alan pulling a late one
或许 明天就要结案了 Might be. We're closing tomorrow.
今晚你们打算做什么呢 What are you doing tonight
准备 Preparing.
是吗 Right.
你知道关于Sally 她和Alan的事 她还在流血 You know, the whole Sally and Alan thing, she's still pretty raw.
你是说 哦 如果你想要 Meaning Oh, just that if you had any intentions of
吃了她 Eating her
生吃会有些问题 Raw would certainly be problematic.
那些垂死挣扎的踢喊哭叫 半熟的我会喜欢 All that kicking and screaming. Rare often works for me.
烤焦最好 Seared.
抱歉 你在说其他事情 I'm sorry, did you mean something else
我只是替朋友考虑 I'm just looking out for a friend.
看得出来 I see.
考虑到是Sally首先甩了我 Well, given that it was Sally's decision to end our relationship,
你或许该向我表达些友善 perhaps you'd consider looking out for me.
你看上去很好 You seem all right.
你搞清楚 就算Tara想要做任何 Just to clarify, if Tara did have any intention of whatever,
你试图委婉表达的事 euphemism you were in search of,
也和你完全无关 it would, in fact, be none of your business.
而且别再乱想了 Tara没有这样的想法 To put your mind at rest, Tara appears not to have intentions.
是我有 I do.
实际上 就在昨天 In fact, just yesterday,
我向她提议在她办公室里做场爱 I was suggesting to her that we engage in a sexual act in her office,
但她那顽固不化的礼仪廉耻感 but her impenetrable sense of decorum
令人遗憾的阻止了 我们的这场 unfortunately prevented us from
运动 engaging.
你多此一举 That was unnecessary.
这是商业诈骗 It's a scam.
他们向医院收取X元的药费 They charge the hospital X amount of dollars for the drug.
医院于是向医疗保险收钱 The hospital then bills medicare,
其中包括所有老人们所付的钱 a portion of which the senior citizens are paying.
证据表明 The evidence will show
被告Holcomb的药品 that the defendant, Holcomb pharmaceuticals
有系统有预谋的在诈骗老人们的财产 systematically defrauded and bilked senior citizens
难以计数的亿万美元 out of billions and billions of dollars.
在这个国家 老人每天都遭受着歧视 The elderly are discriminated against every single day in this country.
他们总是更难申请驾照延期 They get their driver's licenses yanked,
他们总是那些电话销售的目标 they are targeted by abusive telemarketers.
他们深受着偏见 The prejudice is pervasive.
但你们知道吗 But you know what
他们仍能做一件事情 They still do get one thing.
要求公正 their day in court.
要我提醒该你了吗 Need I point out that it's your turn to talk
我讨厌老人 一直讨厌 他们就像孩子 I hate old people. I always have. They're babies.
所以有一半还要裹着尿布 Hell, there's a reason half of them are in diapers.
老年人 The elderly
给予了这个国家大半的财富 make up a large percentage of the wealth in this country.
他们管理着大多数500强的企业 They run most of the fortune 500 companies.
甚至发动着战争 看在上帝的份上 They're running the war, for god's sakes.
绝大部分是能活能动的健康人 And most of them are viable, healthy people.
他们干嘛了呢 What do they do
65岁退休 然后开始消耗资源 Retire at age 65 and start draining our resources.
这个国家有太多的贫穷 We got enormous poverty in this country.
我们不能告诉我们的孩子 原因就是这些身强体壮 We can't educate our kids partly because these strong-bodied,
头脑清醒的老家伙们 却完全依靠着社会保障在生活 strong-minded senior citizen farts are living off of social security.
我们为什么不能多收点他们的钱 Why shouldn't we overcharge them
Mr. Crane 我不明白你想表达的观点 Mr. Crane, I'm not following your argument here.
那是你白痴 That's because you're a moron.
法官 老人 都该滚开 Judges, old people, they all gotta go.
告诉你们 Mr. Crane Mr. Crane Tell you what
给我的委托人一百万罚金的判决 slap my client with a million-dollar verdict.
我们最后也会转移到消费者头上 We'll pass on the costs to the consumer,
原告觉得自己胜诉了 但我们一分钱也不会损失 the plaintiffs will think they've won, and we won't be out a dime.
陪审团 非常遗憾 我不得不宣布这是一次无效审判 Members of the jury, regretfully, I must declare this proceeding a mistrial.
哦 天啊 真遗憾 Aw, gee, I'm sorry to hear that.
这可要延后很长时间了 是吗 That'll cause a big delay, won't it
下面他就该撤换自己了 Next thing you know, he'll recuse himself
因为我对他出言不逊 because I called him a bad word.
你藐视法庭 You are in contempt.
庭警 羁押Mr. Crane Bailiff, take Mr. Crane into custody.
把我和Martha关一起 好不好 Put me in a cell with Martha, will you
我要和那个女人上床 I gotta have sex with that woman.
预谋了四年 Four years of premeditation,
进行具有杀伤力的训练 he trained in deadly force,
然后他找到了Jared Grant 挑衅打架 then he sought out Jared Grant, provoked a fight,
最后给他的气管致命的一击 and inflicted a deadly blow to his trachea.
可能是他挑起的争斗 Maybe he even did start the fight.
可我们不肯定 没有证据证明 We can't know that. There's no proof of that.
但就算我们这么推测 But even if we're to assume it,
也不能简单的推导到意图谋杀 we simply cannot make the leap to intent to kill.
他为什么要去那 Why else would he go there
为什么要击中他的喉咙 Why else would he punch him in the throat
他为什么要在满屋子的人前这么做 Why would he do it in front of a room full of people
为什么不干脆开车去撞 如果他想杀了他 Why not just run him down with a car if his intent was to kill
Jason Binder去那 正如他说的 Jason Binder went there, as he told you,
只是想让自己去面对 to stand up for himself.
没有其他的了 Nothing more.
糟糕的是 It's bad enough
病人们跑到法庭来 that patients are running to the courts
因为自己生病而状告医生 suing their doctors for all their ills,
更何况这次是幻想中的病 now we have one suing for his imagined ills.
这是场毫无意义的诉讼 This case represents the height in frivolous litigation.
接下来会是什么 What's next
因为恶梦追讨损失 Seeking damages for a bad dream
希望不会 I hope not.
毫无意义 他是这么说的吗 Frivolous, is that what he said
毫无意义 Frivolous
令人震惊 Astonishing.
这个男人 日夜受着折磨 This man, who suffers day in and day out,
剧烈的偏头痛 让他无法工作 migraines so excruciating he cannot work,
身为一个软件工程师 can't endure 10 minutes at his computer,
在电脑前甚至无法坚持10分钟 a trained software engineer.
他遭受辞退 接受检查 And here he is subjecting himself to depositions, to examinations,
忍受律师们让人脑子发麻的唠叨 to the laborious mind-numbing blather of attorneys,
这些都为了什么 毫无意义 all for what Frivolity
六个月来 Bill Morgan每周都向医生求助 For six months, Bill Morgan reached out to his doctor week after week,
每次都被收费超过千元 each time invoiced for thousands and thousands of dollars in sum.
却每次都被打发 And then each time dismissed,
只是拍拍头送他走 patted on the head, and sent on his way.
Mr. Morgan得到过实质性的医治吗 Had Mr. Morgan actually received the right medical care
或着被指导去找一个 or even been directed to a doctor
能给他正确医治的医生 精神科或其他的 who could specifically give him that care, psychiatric or otherwise,
可以减轻他的疼痛 his current state would most likely have been alleviated.
但被告甚至不愿麻烦自己这么做 But the defendant couldn't be bothered to care.
正如Dr. Rayburn自己说的 As Dr. Rayburn told you himself,
他把Bill Morgan当成个吉祥物 he treated Bill Morgan like a mascot.
辩方把他当成个讨厌的麻烦 Opposing counsel regards him as a nuisance.
他是人类 He's a human being.
他是个人啊 He's a human being.
我们教导孩子们 We teach our children
人生来就应有尊严 被尊重 that everyone is entitled to respect and dignity.
可悲的是 How pathetic it is
成年人们却无法遵循 人性这最基本的一点 when adults can't abide such a basic lesson in humanity.
多么荒谬 How unconscionable.
被告请起立 The defendant will please rise.
陪审团主席 陪审团达成一致裁定了吗 Madam Foreperson, the jury has reached a unanimous verdict
是的 阁下 We have, your honor.
裁决是 What say you
州政府诉Jason Binder In the case of the commonwealth vs. Jason Binder,
一级谋杀指控 on the charge of murder in the first degree,
我们判定被告Jason Binder 罪名不成立 we find the defendant Jason Binder not guilty.
二级谋杀指控 On the charge of murder in the second degree,
我们判定被告Jason Binder 罪名不成立 we find the defendant Jason Binder not guilty.
感谢陪审团 你们可以解散了 The jury is dismissed with our thanks.
被告当庭释放 The defendant is free to go.
休庭 We're adjourned.
太感谢了 Thank you so much.
谢谢 Thank you.
我听说来恭喜的源源不绝 I'm told congratulations are in order.
你也是 You too.
Denny争取到了时间 我听说了 Denny bought you some time, I hear.
我父亲是刑事辩护律师 My father was a criminal defense attorney.
他认为那是维护公民的权力 He went into it to champion civil rights,
对抗非正义的压迫 to defend the oppressed,
和普通人紧密联系在一起 to connect with people.
但我所见到的却是在晚餐桌前 But all I ever saw at the supper table
一个男人不停的与一个念头斗争 was a man struggling to deal with the idea
他在帮助杀人犯们回到大街上 that he helped put murderers back on the street.
回家 Heading home
监狱 朋友被囚禁 Jail. Incarcerated friend.
你总与危险为伍 You run with a dangerous crowd.
我在尝试 I try.
我也是 As do I.
我可不这么认为 I don't think that's quite true.
你并不了解我 Alan Shore You don't know me, Alan Shore,
不如你自认为的那样 是吗 not as well as you think.No
是 更不如我了解你 No, certainly not as well as I know you.
有多了解 How well is that
我知道一共有三个Alan Shores I know that there are three Alan Shores
好的 坏的 调皮的 the good, the bad, and the naughty.
好的Alan The good Alan,
是我今天在庭上所见的 正直可敬 the man that I saw today in court, is honorable and decent.
但你无法承受那样做人的负担 But you can't bear the burden of being that man.
于是 那个坏的Alan Thus, the bad Alan
荒废生命的那个成了最好选择 who lays to waste everything in his life that seems right.
我其实有想法 I do have intentions.
我的想法是要超越那个坏的 My intentions are to get beyond the bad,
于是我一遍遍召唤那个好的 which I've tried to do again and again by appealing to the good.
但现在看来 或许 But it appears to me that perhaps
我应该召唤那个调皮的 I should be appealing to the naughty.
我不知道我认识的Tara Wilson 还有这样的任务 I'm not certain that Tara Wilson I know is up to the task.
所以 你并不了解我 Alan Again, you don't know me, Alan.
给你的文件 File for you.
你的保释金是6百万美元 不错 Your bail was set at $6 million. Fine.
我买了个汉堡给你 I brought you a hamburger.
这里的看守非常好客 The guards here are extremely hospitable.
我争取到了32万美元的裁决 I just got a jury verdict for $320,000.
Lori负责的谋杀案得到了无罪判定 Lori got a not guilty in her murder case.
你聪明的编导了一场无效审判 You cleverly orchestrated a mistrial,
一个我迷恋的女人 and a woman I'm infatuated with
用一个文件夹送给了我她的小裤裤 delivered to me her panties in a manila folder.
我觉得我们应该要喝一杯 I think we're obliged to have a drink.
干杯 Cheers.
我不是聪明 I wasn't clever.
我是不记得了 I forgot.
什么 I beg your pardon
我站起来 I stood up,
脑子里装满委托人的那些操作流程 armed with all the facts of our client's billing practices,
然后 and
我在陪审团前突然一片空白 I went blank in front of the jury.
我什么也想不起来 I couldn't remember a damn thing.
有时可能会发生的 Well, that can happen sometimes.
你曾经说过怀疑我得了 You once said you suspected I had
海茨默氏综合症 Alzheimer's.
怎么能确诊 How does a person know
这个 Well
还没有精确的诊断 there's no exact diagnostic.
但他们能做一些测试 They can do certain tests.
Denny Denny
你也许在开头走了神 you may have gone upon an opening,
但你立刻补救 还争取到了无效审判 but to recover like that and go for the mistrial,
这说明你是个健康的思维敏捷的人 that's evidence of a man thinking quickly on his feet.
我要做测试 I wanna take the test.