波士顿法律 前情提要 Previously on Boston legal
我用长柄锅打了她的头 I hit her on the head with a skillet.
啊 我该怎么办 Ah What am I do
Bernard Ferrion 你涉嫌谋杀Della Ferrion 现将你予以逮捕 Bernard Ferrion, you're under arrest for the murder of Della Ferrion.
因为袭击你母亲他们上周拘捕了你 They arrested you last week for whacking your mother,
你偶然才做那的 you got off on a technicality,
现在隔壁的那女人因为头上那一下快要死了 now the woman next door turns up dead from a blow to the head.
他们会怎么想你呢 What could possibly make them think of you
现在出去 我不会为罪人辩护的 Now go away. I do not represent evil people.
那个得到临时限制命令的律师说 他是你儿子 The lawyer who got the T.R.O. He says he's your son.
Donny Crane Denny Crane Donny Crane.Denny Crane.
你给了我Crane这个姓 我全指望靠它生活了呢 You gave me the Crane legacy, and I fully plan on living up to it.
他不是我儿子 很显然 他并不知道 He's not my son. Obviously, he doesn't know.
你不是我父亲 我不是你儿子 You're not my father I'm not your son
我不是你儿子 I'm not your son.
告诉我他在哪 Tell me where he is
告诉我他在哪 不然我打断你的胳膊 Tell me where he is, or I'm gonna break your arm
告诉我 不然我打断你的胳膊 Tell me, or I'm gonna break your arm
ABC电视台的现场秀吗 ABC's latest reality show
这是受害家庭的一个成员拍的 That was taken by one of the victim's family members.
我明白 有了这片子我们还有什么可为他辩护的 I see. Why go to his aid when you can get the footage
我干吗在这 Shirley Why am I here, Shirley
我们为警局辩护 也就是为那位警官辩护 We represent the police union, and accordingly, the officer.
我需要你做我的副手 I need you to second chair me at the trial.
我不能做 I can't do it.
你不是说真的是吗 你说对了 我要说的就是 我不会 You don't mean to say that. You're right. The word is won't.
你在刑事案件上经验更丰富 You have more experience with criminal defense work.
我希望我的当事人多少有一点人性 I like my clients to have a modicum of humanity.
我们不都这样希望吗 Don't we all in the meantime.
我不会做的 Shirley I'm not doing it, Shirley.
那警官让我恶心 我不会为他的自由做什么 That officer disgusts me. I won't contribute to his freedom.
我不是希望你为他做什么 I wasn't expecting you to do it for him.
那就是你认为的吗 傻瓜 Is that what you think, silly
听着 我希望你做这案子是因为 事务所每年付你 $375,000的薪水 See, I expect you to do it because this firm pays you $375,000 a year.
那是一大笔钱 Alan 我希望你想着它做这案子 That's a lot of money, Alan, and we expect you to work for it,
甚至因为它你得做些你不情愿的事 even when it requires doing things that don't quite agree with you.
我希望你做这案子因为我们的一位合伙人 噢 不 听着 I expect you to do it because a senior partner is, oh, no, check that,
是我这个合伙人叫你做的 the senior partner is asking you to do it.
我希望你做是因为 I expect you to do it because
你总提到那些没原则没灵魂的娼妓律师 you so often refer to lawyers as unprincipled soulless whores.
那么 接下来的几天 我要你做我的娼妓 Well, for the next few days, I need you to be my whore.
如果你认为这非常冒犯你的话 我猜你会辞职的吧 And if that so offends you, I guess you could always quit.
不过我可以告诉你 But I warn you,
你还是会被记起的 you will be missed
至少在最初的5分钟里 for at least all of five minutes.
波士顿法律 第一季 第十五集 扭曲的灵魂 Boston Legal 1x15. Tortured Souls
ABC首次放送时间 ： 2005/02/20 ORIGINAL AIR DATE ON ABC: 2005/02/20
呃 Crane先生在哪 Uh, where's Mr. Crane
早上9点他可能在任何地方 At 9:00 in the morning, he could be many places.
怎么了 嗯 打和解官司时他会在场吗 Why / Well, will he be present for the settlement conference
他应该会 但首先还是让我们 He should be. But first let's
那么如果达不成和解 他还会继续做这案子吗 and if it doesn't settle, will he be trying it
Frannie 让我们谈下这个问题 好 Frannie, let's talk here. Okay.
我们打算和解 我们一定要和解 We're going to settle. It must settle.
起诉一个在结婚礼坛上逃跑的男人 Suing a man for being left at the altar
是在300个人面前 in front of 300 people
法庭不喜欢搅到这类案子里 courts don't like to get involved in breakups.
我不是在安慰你 我说的都是事实 Not to discount your pain, which I'm sure is real.
我们想着陪审团会做一个有利于我们的判决 We are looking at the very real possibility of a directed verdict against us.
考虑到这 我的建议是你接受私下和解 In light of that, my recommendation is that you accept the offer.
呃 接受那17万5千美金 Uh, for $175,000
是的 Yes.
喔 不 Oh, no.
呃 Denny Crane说我可以拿到更多 Um, Denny Crane promised me more.
他说你可以拿到多少 Frannie How much did he promise you, Frannie
5百万美金 $5 million.
也许我真的该辞职 Maybe I should quit.
我是谁 我是怎么样的 这个女人一点也不知道 This woman has no idea who or what I am.
想开点吧 Lighten up, man.
首先 给那种混蛋做辩护 First of all, the idea of giving representation to that thug
Alan 得了吧 哪个当事人我们不讨厌 Alan, come on, we hate all our clients.
恨他们没什么不好 It's good to hate them.
恨他们我们就能从他们那多收点钱 恨他们我们晚上也能睡好觉 It allows us to overcharge and still sleep at night.
我想她至少也要耍点新手段吧 I thought her gamesmanship would at least be more nuanced.
Alan 昨晚我太过强硬了 对不起 Alan, I'm sorry for becoming abrupt last night.
事情很简单 我需要你 这不是件容易的案子 The simple fact is, I need you. It's a difficult case.
还有 你如果做了会得到什么呢 Also, for what it's worth,
我好像总是和我不想与之上床的男人争吵 I've been known to get contentious with men I unconsciously want to bed.
我完全不能想象和你上床 I can't possibly imagine wanting to have sex with you,
不过说起来 我确实与Denny做过 but then again, I did sleep with Denny.
啊 我们该走了 10点开庭 Uh, we should go. The trial starts at 10:00.
我会做这案子 就坐在她身边 I will do this case. Sit by her side.
还有什么理由比搞定她更充分的 For no other reason than to solve her.
Alan 对不起 Alan, I'm sorry.
那个侏儒又来了 The midget is back.
你说什么 就那个矮男人 他又来了 I beg your pardon The little man, he's here.
天哪 你又杀了谁 Alan Alan. / Good gracious. Who have you killed now
这问题真伤人 那你为什么在这 Bernard That question is extremely hurtful. Why are you here, Bernard
啊 我只是顺便过来打个招呼 Well, uh, I just dropped by to say hello.
我刚刚就在隔壁 I was in the neighborhood.
你好吗 How are you
Bernie 我马上要去上庭 我没时间和你说了 Bernie, I'm due in court. I don't have time to talk to you.
你可以和Catherine说说你的事 如果有的话 State your business, if you have any, with Catherine,
我会打电话给你的 and I'll call you back.
原谅我 Forgive me.
和矮人呆在一起我会不舒服 I'm uncomfortable around little people.
我问问你 Bernie Let me ask you, Bernie,
你曾经想过聆听神的福音吗 have you ever thought about finding god
我们能谈一下吗 Can we talk a second
闭锁装弹 Lock and load.
当事人在哪 Where's the client
我送她回去了 她在这没什么必要 I sent her home. She doesn't need to be here for this.
噢 看在上帝份上 Oh, for god's sake
Crane先生 你告诉她我们能帮她弄到5百万吗 Mr. Crane, did you tell the client we could get her $5 million
我也许说了 怎么了 这案子最多判十多万块 I might've. So / The case values out in the low six figures.
你这么想好像这案子不需要公共事务局决定一样 That's assuming it doesn't get tossed out on public policy grounds.
听着 年轻人 做案子的第一秘诀 Listen, young lady, first rule of thumb when practicing law,
一定要 经常要许诺当事人能拿到成百万的钱 always, always promise the client millions and millions of dollars.
这是项好生意 It's good business.
这么一个荒唐的许诺还会好吗 And when it comes time to making good on such a ridiculous claim
Donny Crane Donny Crane.
Donny Crane 你记得我吧 Donny Crane. You remember me.
我们过去是父亲和儿子 We used to be father and son.
见到你很高兴 Michael Gendler 在哪 Nice to see you. Where's Michael Gendler
我是被告的新律师 I'm appearing as the defendant's new counsel.
那$175,000 现在没了 顺便说一句 那价钱可太高了 That $175,000, it's off the table. By the by, way too high.
我们现在只出$50,000 We'll go to $50,000.
Donny Crane Donny Crane.
那不可能被接受 That's rejected.
喔 没有点钞机吗 Whoa. No counter
$350,000 $350,000.
喔 喔 Double whoa.
好了 这么说有官司要打了 是吗 Well, guess that means a trial, huh
够酷 Cool.
比我有经验 More experience for me.
Donny Crane Donny Crane.
Denny Crane Donny crane Denny Crane.Donny crane.
你做这案子是因为我在做这案子吧 You got on this case specifically because I'm on it.
就是这样 你想打败我吗 I did. You wanna get me
我想 我喜欢这样 I do. I love it.
Denny Crane Donny Crane Denny Crane.Donny Crane.
我们收到线报 呃 关于疑犯Damon Harris We had received a tip that the, uh, suspect Damon Harris
线报说他去见他哥哥Paul 所以我们就去了他哥哥家 was visiting his brother Paul, so we went to the brother's house.
那么你们在那找到疑犯了吗 对不起 And did you find the suspect Excuse me.
我是刚刚做这个案子的 这里的陪审团 当然了 I'm new to this case, as is the jury, of course.
是帮助我们寻找真相的 To help us track the facts,
我想知道你是否能指认他就是绑架疑犯 I was wondering if you could refer to him as the kidnapping suspect,
这样我们就能弄清我们在讨论的是 关于一个劫持了6岁儿童的男人 so we're clear that we're talking about the man who snatched a 6-year-old child.
那孩子就坐在这 The boy is sitting right over here.
绑架疑犯在那吗 警官 Was the kidnapping suspect there, officer
不 No.
他的哥哥在那吗 在 The brother was there Yes.
你能告诉我们发生过什么吗 Could you tell us what happened
好 我们搜查了那所房子 Well, we searched the premises.
没有找到疑犯 Couldn't find the kidnapping suspect.
我们询问他的哥哥他是否知道些什么 We asked the brother if he knew his whereabouts.
他说他不知道 那么接下来发生了什么 He claimed he did not. And then what happened
接下来发生的就是你在那录像带上看到的 What happened is basically what you saw on the tape.
我的同事开始 呃 开始 对他哥哥的询问更强硬 My partner began to, uh, interrogate the brother more coercively.
在任何时间 这案子的受害人 At any time, was the victim of this attack
被错认做绑架疑犯了吗 considered a suspect himself in the kidnapping
没有 No.
你从没认为他和那案子有关吗 You never considered him connected to the crime
是的 没有 No.
正如Shore先生陈述 你们试图寻找现在坐在那的那位6岁的男孩 As Mr. Shore noted, you were trying to find the 6-year-old boy seated over here.
是的 这案子发生前 他已经被绑架多久了 Yes. / He was kidnapped how long before this incident
这事发生的前天 The day before.
时间越来越少 你们找到活着被绑架孩子的机会有多大 As time goes by, what are the chances of finding a kidnapped child alive
48小时之后 我们就认为很难再有希望了 After 48 hours, we consider it extremely remote.
实际上 我们讨论的那位绑架疑犯 In fact, the kidnapper we're talking about
曾经有过绑架另一个男孩的案底 是吗 is suspected in the kidnapping of another boy, correct
是的 你们找到那个男孩了吗 Yes. Did you ever find that boy
我们只找到他的尸体 We found his remains.
那么当我的当事人正对他的哥哥实施强硬行为时 While my client was committing his coercive acts against the brother,
你做了什么 我退后了 what did you do I stood back.
你没有干预吗 You never intervened
没有 No.
你报告了这件事吗 Did you report it
一开始没有 呃 后来有 Not at first, uh, eventually.
顺便问一下 我的当事人实施完强硬行为的结果 By the way, as a result of my client's physical coercive acts,
疑犯的哥哥告诉你们什么了 did the brother tell you anything
他给了我们一张他弟弟可能会出现地方的单子 He gave us a list of places his brother would frequent.
那么你们搜查了这些地方吗 And did you search those places
是的 Yes.
有收获吗 And
我们找到了疑犯 We found the suspect.
还有那孩子 And the child.
谢谢 Thank you.
我想说的是 All I'm saying is,
如果你杀过两个人 而且如果你真像你说的那么孤独 if you killed two people and if you're as alone as you say,
那么现在就是你投入耶稣 你的救主的最好时间 there couldn't be a better time for you to turn to Jesus Christ, your savior.
在通常情况下 我同意 Under normal circumstances, I'd agree.
那为什么不呢 我是个犹太人 But I'm Jewish.
Bernie 从没有过犹太人是连环杀手的 Bernie, there has never ever been a Jewish serial killer.
萨姆小子 David Berkowitz 就是 Son of Sam. David Berkowitz.
他后来信耶稣了 He was adopted.
他是我们的一员 Genetically, he's one of ours.
好了 你想说什么 Well, what are you saying
我想说如果你杀了人 I am saying that if you're out there murdering people,
不管在什么程度上 你一定想成为基督徒的 on some level, you must want to be christian.
你能让我带你去教堂吗 Would you let me take you to church
我很欣赏你打败那老家伙的勇气 I've gotta admire your guts to take a piece of the old man.
那是因为怒火中烧 There's a fire in the belly.
你也是个老家伙 也不是我的父亲 记得吗 Yeah, you're an old man. Just not mine, remember
是 Yeah.
事实是 The thing is
我欣赏你 实际上 I like you. Actually
我爱你 I love you.
让Denny Crane这么说真不是容易事 That's a difficult thing for Denny Crane to say
除非是前戏 unless it's part of foreplay.
我爱你 Donny I love you, Donny,
我关心的是 and I'm concerned that
如果你在法庭上和我对着来 你会 if you go up against me in a court of law you'll
我来就是为了说这个 I might as well just come out and say it.
我不可能被打败的 I can't be beat.
真的吗 从没失败 永不会失败 Really. Never lost. Never will.
我在salmon的案子里打败过你 你打败的是 Brad Chase I beat you in the salmon case. You beat Brad Chase.
我 没被打败过 我明白了 Me undefeated. I see.
好 我为什么做这案子 Well, how do I put this
我做案子就是为了给你点颜色瞧瞧 I took this case mainly to kick your fat lying ass.
我要的就是这个 I mean that in a good way.
我会打败你的 I will beat you.
不 你不会 是 我会的 No, you won't. Yes, I will.
不会 我会 Won't. I will.
不会 我会 Won't. Will.
儿子 别那么叫我 Son. Don't call me that.
我想再这么叫一次 I'm gonna say this one more time
用上我所有的谦逊 with all the humility I can summon up.
从没有过我这么好的律师 I'm the greatest trial attorney that ever lived.
你打不败我 You will not beat me.
我不知道你听到了多少 I don't know how much you just heard.
我的屁股也许会说谎 My ass may lie
但它全是肌肉 but it's all muscle.
我知道他了解些什么 I knew he knew something.
或者知道他弟弟在哪 或者知道那孩子在哪 Either where his brother was or where the child was.
他一定知道些什么 He knew something.
所以你准备打他让他说 And you were prepared to beat it out of him.
我那时只想打他 吓吓他 I was prepared to punch him, to intimidate him.
我没真的想弄断他的胳膊 I didn't actually mean to break his arm.
但是 Kirkland 先生 我们在录像带上看到的 But, Mr. Kirkland, what we saw on that tape
在绑架案里有不同的规定 你说的不同的规定是什么意思 there are different rules in kidnappings. What do you mean, different rules
意思是我们不打算打碎谁的骨头 或者造成什么永久伤害 The understanding is we're not supposed to break bones or cause any permanent injury,
但是身体的这类强制是被允许的 but physical discomforture is permitted.
比如使肩膀脱臼 肌肉弄伤 都是允许的 It's okay to say, dislocate a shoulder, tear a muscle.
你所指的是拷问 而你当时对待的是一个无辜的人 You're talking about torture. This was an innocent man.
他并不是绑架疑犯 He wasn't even the suspected kidnapper.
我很对不起我弄伤他了 And I'm sorry I hurt him,
但是我那时觉得他应该知道他弟弟在哪 but I felt he knew where his brother was.
我想我的行为应该是像正当防卫 或者是为了别人所做出的防卫 I consider this to be like self-defense or defense of others.
为了救那孩子我那时会做任何事 I was gonna do whatever I could to save that boy.
我能想到的是我自己的儿子 All I could think about was my own son.
为了正当目的可以不择手段吗 The end justifies the means
我想我不得不回答是 I guess I have to say yes to that.
假如那个绑架案疑犯向一位神父忏悔过 Suppose the suspected kidnapper had confessed to a priest.
你觉得你揍一位神父去获得你要的会没关系吗 You'd feel no compunction about beating up clergy to get your information
我没那么说 那么 这有什么不同吗 I didn't say that. Well, is there a distinction
一个知道些什么的无辜者可能会帮忙去找到孩子 An innocent man has information that would lead to the recovery of a child.
我那时感觉此案的受害者并不那么无辜 I guess I felt the victim here wasn't so innocent.
啊 所以那时你开始审判了 是吗 Ah, so you're out there playing judge, too
警察 法官 执行者 Policeman, judge, executioner
反对 反对有效 Objection. / Sustained.
谁告诉你把人肌肉弄伤 Who told you it was okay to tear muscles
让人肩膀脱臼在绑架案里是可以的 and dislocate shoulders in kidnapping situations
没有正式的说明 我只是这么认为的 There's no formal directive. Just understood.
到警察因为你做过的把你逮捕后 你还这么认为吗 Understood by the police who arrested you after you did it
我被逮捕只是因为媒体得到了那录像带 I was arrested because the media got a hold of this.
那是我现在在这的唯一原因 That's the only reason I'm here.
还有什么比这更糟的 How sad is that
你虐待一个没有犯罪记录无辜的人 You tortured an innocent man with no criminal record
他唯一的罪过就是他逃亡的弟弟逃到了他家 whose only offense was that his fugitive brother stopped at his house,
而你在这的唯一原因 就是因为媒体得到了那录像带 and the only reason you're here is because the media got a hold of it.
Frannie 你愿意吗 把Michael作为你的合法丈夫 Do you, Frannie, take Michael to be your lawfully wedded husband,
无论此时或之后 for here and ever after
我愿意 I do.
你呢 Michael 你愿意吗 把Frannie作为你的合法妻子 And do you, Michael, take Frannie to be your lawfully wedded wife,
无论此时或之后 for here andver after
Michael Michael.
Michael 你愿意吗 把Frannie作为你的合法妻子 Do you, Michael, take Frannie to be your lawfully wedded wife,
无论此时或之后 for here and ever after
Michael Michael
对不起 我不能 I'm sorry. I can't.
我真的不能 I just can't.
我用我的一生等待这一天 I waited my whole life for this day.
我的朋友 我的家人 My friends, my family
他们都聚在一起庆祝我生命中最快乐的日子 they were all gathered to celebrate the happiest event in my life.
可结果呢 他们看到了这么一件丢脸的事情 And instead, they were witness to such a humiliation.
因为这件事 我精神上仍然饱受伤害 I'm still reeling from it psychologically.
你要求心理治疗了吗 Did you require treatment
是的 接受了好几个月的治疗 Yes. For many, many months.
我的医生认为这创伤会让我 很难再找到爱情了 My therapist thinks the trauma is even an inhibitor to my finding love again.
他有过任何暗示他在这件事上有摇摆吗 Had he given any indication at all that he was wavering
不 没有 None. No.
一切都看起来好好的 Everything was fine.
诶 实际上 那些日子他更好了 很完美 Um, it was more than fine, actually. It was perfect.
只到那天 突然的 Until suddenly, um
呃 就如你们看到的 well, what you saw.
我和300个从各地赶来的人在教堂里 I'm in the church with 300 people gathered from all over.
而他 He just, um
你们看到了 well, you saw it.
你怎么说呢 What are you saying
如果他不感到有罪 If he didn't feel committed,
他本应该娶你就因为结婚的酒席已经付了钱吗 he should've married you just the same because the catering was paid for
如果他不感到有罪 我们在这在干什么 If he didn't feel committed, what were we doing up there
我 我那时穿着礼服 我的结婚礼服 I, I was standing in my gown, my wedding dress.
但是这是关于爱情的事 Frannie But this is love, Frannie.
爱情总是会有意想不到的事 It takes funny unexpected bounces.
我们讨论的是心里的感觉 We're talking about emotions of the heart.
反对 Objection.
听起来像个娘娘腔 要单挑吗 Sounds like a girly man. Move to strike
那还不错 Crane先生 That's better. Mr. Crane.
Frannie 你认为我的当事人是计划好这么做的吗 Frannie. Do you think my client planned for it to go down like this
你知道那是什么样的震撼吗 Do you have any idea what a jolt it was
你期待一生的一天 却被人抛弃在教堂里 to be left standing in the church on a day that you've been planning for a lifetime
你看到坐那的那人了吗 Denny Crane You see that guy over there Denny Crane
他装作是我的父亲25年了 He pretended to be my father for 25 years.
我知道那种震撼当我 反对 I know a good jolt when I Objection
你失去了个未婚夫 我失去了个世界 You lost a fiance. I lost a foundation.
反对 Crane先生 Objection Mr. Crane.
感情重创是生活的一部分 Emotional wallops are a part of life.
你不应该跑到法庭来说这些 You don't go running into court to address them.
这正是你正在做的事 That's exactly what you're doing now.
你闭嘴 律师先生 You shut up Counsel
对不起 I'm sorry.
我向法庭道歉 I apologize to the court.
有些时候痛苦能让你失去控制 Sometimes pain can cause you to lash out.
你同意吗 Frannie Would you agree with that, Frannie
如果那伤害足够深 If the hurt was deep enough,
你想打击让你经受这些的那个人 是吗 you'd want to lash out at the person who caused it
你现在来法庭是不是有点就因为这个呢 Is it possible you're doing just a little of that here, hmm
掩饰的真自然 看起来像全计划好的 其实不是 That recovery was so smooth it almost looked planned, but it wasn't.
我全知道 I gotcha.
你不知道 我知道 You don't got me. I do.
不 你不知道 知道 No, you don't. Do.
别装了 先生 你在反驳一个律师 Don't. Sir, you're opposing counsel.
除非你想摆平这案子 Unless you want to settle the case.
那不是什么重点 得那么一分 That isn't the point, to settle a score.
你让我在我整个生命里相信你就是我父亲 You caused me to believe you were my father for my entire life.
你以为你做的能这么算了吗 You think that score can be evened up
Rhina Rhina.
Chelina Chelina.
我决定让被告倒点霉了 I've decided to take the defendant's cross.
Crane先生 我想那不是个好主意 Mr. Crane, I'm not sure that's a good idea.
那么首先 这是谁的主意 Well, whose idea is it
你的 那它就一定是个好主意 Yours. Well, it must be good.
Crane先生 你知道这案子是关于什么的吗 Mr. Crane, do you even know what this case is about
关于钱的 案子总是关于钱的 It's about money. They're always about money.
我强烈建议你把这案子交给我处理 I strongly suggest you let me handle this.
啊 这么 How about
这么 How about
这么 哪些爱国者怎么办 How about those patriots
没有 从没有过 Never ever, ever,
我们发出过这样的信息 直接的间接的或者以其他什么方式 did we send the message, directly, indirectly, or otherwise,
说明对嫌犯或者证人进行身体侵害 是可以接受的 that it is acceptable procedure to physically coerce suspects or witnesses.
警官说这很容易明白 Officer Kirkland says it was understood
在绑架案里用些不同的规则 that with kidnapping cases there's a different set of rules.
他错了 He's mistaken.
我们的部门是服务于民众 保护民众的 Our department is to serve and protect the public,
当然也包括尊重他们的公民自由权利 and that includes honoring their civil liberties.
那么在你看来 他所做的已经超出了 他的职责范围了 做为一名警官的职责 So he was acting outside the scope of his authority as a police officer, in your opinion.
他所做的超出了法律的范围 He was acting outside the scope of the law.
他承认实施了恶意的攻击行为 He committed a vicious criminal assault.
这真丢脸 It was disgraceful.
每次我都看不下去那录像 I'm repulsed every time I see that footage.
您提到那录像真是件有趣的事 上尉 That's a funny thing that you mention footage, captain,
那录像在新闻上一播出 我的当事人就被逮捕了 because my client wasn't arrested until that video was aired on the news.
在播出前我们就在进行调查 We were investigating prior to that broadcast.
啊 你们那时正在调查 Ah. You were investigating.
告诉我 你第一次听到我当事人的这行为 是什么时候 Tell me, when did you first hear about my client's conduct
我记不起来了 也许我能帮你记起来 I can't really recall. Maybe I can help out.
受害者做了份控诉还填了份书面报告 The, uh, victim made a complaint and filed a written report
就在这件事发生的当天 他的家人可以证实 the day that it happened. His family members verified it.
你能确定我当事人不光彩的行为是 从那天开始的 是吗 上尉 You had knowledge of my client's disgraceful acts from day one, didn't you, captain
还有 当他们发现那孩子时 And yet, when they recovered the child,
你开了个新闻发布会以表彰破案的警官 you held a press conference singing the praises of your officers,
也包括Kirkland先生 including Mr. Kirkland.
而当录像带在新闻播出后 Then, when the footage went out over the airwaves,
突然之间我当事人的行为就变成不光彩的了 suddenly my client's conduct became disgraceful.
我们没有过也永不会原谅私刑 We have not ever, and will not ever, condone torture.
Alan Dershowitz 刚刚说如果我们有一个被拘捕的嫌犯 Alan Dershowitz recently said that if we had a suspect in custody
他正好知道有个炸弹马上要爆炸了 将会杀死很多人 who knew that a bomb was about to go off and kill people,
这时就得用私刑了 你同意吗 torture would be used. Do you disagree with that
我们现在这没有什么炸弹的事情 所以我回答不了 We've never had such a ticking bomb case here, so I can't answer.
那让我们说我们正在调查一个大恐怖分子的案子 Let's say we're trying to crack a big terrorist case.
比如说 泛美航空的客机在洛克比爆炸了 Say, the Pan Am jet that went down in Lockerbie.
那么这案子私刑能用吗 你应该去问联邦调查局 Was torture used there You'd have to ask the FBI.
有些报告 也许我该说是流言 关于洛克比的流言 There were reports, I should say rumors about the Lockerbie case,
据说有带电的装置被装在了囚犯的生殖器上 that electrical devices were attached to the prisoners' genitalia.
你熟悉 反对 Are you familiar Objection.
这个法庭是不会承认流言的 Schmidt 女士 This court is not going to admit rumors, Ms. Schmidt.
上尉 让我来问你一些事情 Let me ask you something, captain.
如果他们经受私刑 你会在乎吗 If they were tortured, do you care
我真惊讶你最后一个问题 I was surprised by your last question.
最后一个问题是我们的防御 Alan The last question is our defense, Alan,
这就是我需要你的原因 我需要你做结案陈词 which is the reason I need you to close.
结案陈词 我还不知道怎么着手呢 Close I still don't even know what I'm doing on this case, much less
你得了结这案子 Shirley You're on this case to close. Shirley.
我会给你买点喝的慢慢解释 8点在我办公室碰面 I'll buy you a drink and explain. Meet me in my office at 8:00.
怎么了 What's going on
我也完全不了解到底怎么了 I haven't the slightest idea what's going on.
我不知道为什么接了这案子 I'm on this case for no apparent reason.
Catherine Catherine.
嗨 你好 亲爱的 Oh, hello, dear.
我不想你对Bernard Ferrion很友善 I do not want you be friending Bernard Ferrion.
嘿 你这么说好像这关你什么事一样 Gee, you say that almost as if it's any of your business.
那个男人已经杀了两个人了 你和他在一起不安全 The man has murdered two people. It is unsafe for you to keep his company.
我已经为拯救别人的灵魂努力82年了 他很危险 而且他 I've managed to survive for 82 years He is dangerous, and he
要我说 我觉得他很绝望 Catherine My word would be desperate. Catherine,
Bernard Ferrion 很邪恶 他很可能还会再杀人的 Bernard Ferrion is evil. He will likely murder again,
而你 可能真有人活该像那样头上被挨一下 and you, if ever there was a person who deserved a whack on the head
上帝 God
什么 What
我的确是打算娶她的 I absolutely planned to marry her.
那么 到底发生了什么呢 Mike Well What happened, Mike
我只是 我只是很恐惧 I just I panicked.
在那个时刻吗 At that particular moment
听着 我有点恐惧症 如果我的生活失去控制的话 Look, I had a phobic kind of thing about losing control of my life.
Frannie 她 她办了结婚宴席 Frannie, she, she picked out the caterer,
教堂 牧师 大厅 这都让我恐惧 the church, the minister, the reception hall, and it just hit me.
那场婚礼就像是婚姻的缩影 That wedding was a microcosm of marriage,
每个决定都是她做出的 with every decision to be made by her.
我只是恐惧 I just panicked.
你没想过你那样做会让她多窘迫吗 Didn't you think of how embarrassing it would be for her
我也一样窘迫 我站在那就像个傻瓜 And for me, too. I was the one standing up there looking like an idiot,
那个时候 要么说出来 要么永远沉默 but we were at the speak now or forever hold your peace part.
我有什么其他选择吗 What other choice did I have
谢谢 Thank you.
我得说 刚才我们看到了最好的Donny Crane I must say, we've all just seen the best of Donny Crane.
反对 收回 Objection. Withdrawn, withdrawn.
Mitch 我能叫你Mitch 吗 Mitch, may I may I call you Mitch
我的名字是 Michael My name's Michael.
就我理解你的证言 你只是还没准备好结婚 As I understand your testimony, you just weren't ready to get married.
是的 那不是个小决定 它将影响你的一生 That's right. / It's a huge decision. It affects your whole life.
是的 它也将影响她的一生 Yes. It affects her life.
当然 Of course.
你 你应该是那种考虑事情很周到的人 是吗 You, you seem like a considerate sort of guy. Are you
我想是的 你一定有想到过 呃 I think so. You must've sensed that, uh,
当你把她抛弃在结婚礼坛上时 那对她将是一个巨大的打击 when you left her at the altar like that, it would be a big number on her.
你不会对这个一点概念也没有 You weren't insensitive to that.
不 我想重复一遍 No, but again
除那之外我还能做什么呢 啊 是 what else could I have done Well, yes.
这么说是不是不合理 Would it be unreasonable to say .
新郎突然感到要改变主意 that the groom incurs a duty to perhaps sort out his feelings
在结婚典礼30分钟前 before 30 minutes into the ceremony
啊 这个 这不合理 是吗 Well, uh That's not unreasonable, is it
当新郎走在走廊上时终于拿定了主意 for the groom to be sure before he walks down the aisle
这是不是不合理 Is that unreasonable
我想不是 I guess not.
你曾经对她说过你很抱歉吗 Ever tell her you're sorry
当然 我说过 你想现在再对她说吗 Of course I did. Want to tell her now
我很抱歉 Frannie, I'm sorry.
啊 Mitch 我的名字是 Michael And, Mitch My name's Michael.
你的律师叫什么名字 What's your lawyer's name
我叫什么名字 Donny Crane Donny Crane. What's my name
很大的不同 不是吗 Denny Crane Denny Crane. Big difference, isn't there
接着来啊你 Crane 先生 Move to strike. Mr. Crane.
现在你懂了 Now you got it.
闭锁装弹 Lock and load.
我爱法律 I love the law.
那到底什么是你们的防御呢 And what exactly is your defense
有点像这样 你放他走 尽管他确实会这么做 Something like let him go, even though he did it.
陪审团宣布无罪 Jury nullification.
我只能说这么多了 因为Shirley也没真的告诉我 Best I can tell, though Shirley hasn't really filled me in.
在谈我吗 是的 Shirley Talking about me Yes, Shirley,
如果你喜欢把我蒙在鼓里 if you so enjoy keeping me in the dark,
那你真该让我试试 you really should give me a try
在黑暗里 in the dark.
谢谢 Thank you.
实际上正是你黑暗的爱让你接了这案子 Actually, it's your love of the dark that got you on this case.
我们8点还要约吗 Are we still on for 8:00
你说的好像有什么其他意思 See, that evidently was supposed to mean something.
对不起 Bernie Excuse me. Bernie
你在这干什么 What are you doing here
呃 我在 呃 我在接Catherine Uh, I'm, uh, picking up Catherine. We're grabbing a bite.
Bernie 我喜欢Catherine Piper 我非常想她能好好地生活 Bernie, I like Catherine Piper. I very much want her to go on living,
但如果她和你在一起这种可能性就少得多了 the chances of which are lessened if she keeps your company.
去你妈的 你刚才对我说什么 Go screw yourself. What did you just say to me
你听到了 我这样的人本来不该骂人的 You heard me. It's not like me to curse.
我出生到现在为止我还只骂过一次 I've only said it once before in my entire life.
一定是骂你妈妈吧 去你妈的 Alan Undoubtedly to mother. Go screw yourself, Alan
现在你一共骂了三次了 记住这个 我还轮不到你教训 Now we're up to three times. I will not be berated by you, put down.
Catherine 你刚刚看到了吗 Catherine, are you witnessing this
看在上帝份上 你为什么就不能给他一次机会 Why don't you give him a chance, for god's sake
我们能别把上帝扯进来吗 How about we leave god out of this
我雇你来是做秘书的 I hired you to be a legal secretary,
不是让你把上帝或者其他什么人带进办公室 not to bring god or anybody else into the office,
连环杀手更不行 certainly not serial killers.
看他的表情 Catherine Note the look on his face, Catherine.
那在你脸上可是常见到 疯子的表情 That's what's commonly known as your psychotic glare.
没人来催催这家伙让他快点走人吗 Don't anybody ask this man to whip up an omelet.
你曾经是我的朋友 我也认为你也曾经是我的朋友 You were my friend. And I thought you were mine.
你知道我把你弄出来后你做了些什么吗 And you know what you did to me after I got you out
你又杀了人 You killed again.
因为你 沾在我手上的血永远也洗不掉了 You got blood on my hands that will never come out.
朋友是不会那么做的 Bernie 朋友不会那么做的 Friends don't do that, Bernie. Friends don't do that.
啊 你 Oh, you.
你一直的冷观应该有什么见解 Tara Your continued staring suggests a point of view, Tara.
如果你有 请告诉我 If you've got one, please share it.
这是每个女人 可能也是每个男人最坏的恶梦 This is every woman's, perhaps every man's greatest nightmare,
在我们的家人前 在我们的挚友前 在我们的上司前 被离弃在结婚礼坛前 being left at the altar in front of all our family, our closest friends, our boss.
没有比这更大的羞辱了 而这可能发生在每个人身上 There is no greater humiliation. And it could happen to anybody.
这可能发生在你们身上 It could happen to you.
你们的女儿 或者你们的儿子身上 Your granddaughter, your son.
也可能发生在我身上 Me.
我们现在要问问每个新郎和新娘 We gotta send a message right now to every bride and every groom.
你会变心吗 You wanna have a change of heart
这不错 Fine.
但是在你们走上走廊时就做好决定吧 But have the decency to have it before you walk down the aisle.
现在只有一种方法才能真正让 新郎新娘们知道 不是吗 And there's only one way to really send that message, isn't there
就是让我的当事人拿到钱 Money.
他要怎么做呢 What would you have him do
结婚仪式难道比宪法还神圣吗 The ceremony somehow takes precedence over the institution itself
现在我们这场官司就是为了 避免那种窘迫处境吗 The goal is to avoid embarrassment now
这是婚姻 This is marriage.
看在上帝份上 除非死亡把我们分开 For god's sake, till death do us part.
否则让我们永不分离 Let no man tear asunder.
我的当事人做了件值地骄傲的事情 Now, my client did the honorable thing.
他拒绝向他感觉不好的东西宣誓 He refused to take vows he didn't feel he could live up to.
这儿真的有人感到他是有这个权利的吗 And does anybody here really feel he should have
这是婚姻 This is marriage.
让我来做最后陈词真有点疯了 It's simply insane for me to give the closing
特别是在你把所有证人都给问完了之后 after you've handled all the witnesses.
我和陪审团可没什么关系 The jury has no relationship with me.
我猜你就只是需要一个人吧 I can only guess that you must want one.
这难道都是因为 Is that what this is all about,
你隐密的想和我上床的欲望 your unconscious desire to bed me
你一定还没看过这段片子 You have undoubtedly seen this footage.
还有这世界里一些其他的 也没看 Along with the rest of the world.
这发生在洛杉矶 但这和我们有什么关系 It happened in Los Angeles. What's it got to do with us
这两个警官被内部整肃了 然后他们起诉 Two of the officers were disciplined, and they then sued.
上个月他们刚刚被判决获得了240万美元赔偿 They were just awarded $2.4 million last month.
这有什么寓意吗 Is there a moral
这将把我们带到黑暗中 This brings us to the dark.
那案子的陪审团 The jury in that case
有点良心发现所以赔了这些警官数百万美元 somehow found it in their conscience to pay those officers millions of dollars.
很显然 人性起了作用 Obviously, there was some human nature in play.
我们需要站在陪审团面前 We need to stand up in front of our jury
告诉他们我们的当事人做的是件好事 and tell them what our client did was a good thing.
而将要做这的不是我 It's not in me to sell that.
你认为该是我 And you think it's in me.
我还是不完全了解你 Alan I certainly don't know all of you, Alan,
也许一点了解也没有 perhaps not even much.
但是你看起来有种能洞察人黑暗面的能力 But you seem to have a capacity to see darkness in people's hearts.
我需要你去展现这种人性的丑恶 I need you to exploit the ugliness in human nature
用种我做不了的方式 in a way that I cannot.
我想你低估了你自己的这种能力 I think you're underestimating your own capacity to see darkness in hearts.
他不能凌驾于法律之上因为他是个警察 He doesn't get to be above the law because he's a policeman.
他不能免于罪责因为有个偶然的结果 He doesn't get to be exempt from the law because there was a fortuitous result.
他攻击了一个无辜的男人 揍他的脸 He beat up an innocent man, fractured a cheekbone,
弄断他的胳膊 把他送进医院 broke an arm, put him in the hospital.
这是项很严重的故意伤害行为 这是私刑 This was an aggravated assault. It was torture.
Paul Harris没什么疑犯的特别信息 Paul Harris didn't have specific information as to the whereabouts of the suspect.
他仅有的就是一些疑犯可能会出现的地方 All he had was a general idea of the places he liked to frequent.
因为那些 For that
你们就看到了发生在他身上的事情 you saw what happened to him.
事实是 作为美国人 The truth is, as Americans,
我们爱刑讯 we love torture.
我们对自己人用刑讯 但是想想 We keep it to ourselves, of course, but come on,
当它被用来对付罪人时 when it comes to evil doers,
刑讯没什么不好 torture's okay.
好莱坞当然知道这个 Dirty Harry 精彩 Hollywood certainly knows that. Dirty Harry, boom,
Charles Bronson 在death wish里 Charles Bronson in death wish,
Denzel Washington 在man on fire里 Denzel Washington in man on fire,
英雄们总是对坏蛋用刑讯 heroes torturing the bad guys.
在全国的剧场里我们都在欢呼 我们爱刑讯 In theaters all across the country, we cheered. We like torture.
刑讯会被滥用吗 这毫无疑问 Is there potential for abuse Without question.
发生在阿布格莱布监狱的事就很悲惨 The events at Abu Ghraib prison were deplorable.
但我们真的相信他们是无缘无故发生的吗 But do we really believe they just happened in a vacuum
Alberto Gonzales 我们的最高法官 Alberto Gonzales, our attorney general,
给政府写了一个备忘录 上面说 刑讯是可以的 wrote a memo to the administration saying torture's okay.
我们的最高法院也刚刚批准 Our supreme court just recently held
可以采信刑讯得来的证据 that evidence gained from torture can be used in trials.
Alan Dershowitz 我们国家最活跃的公民权利人士之一 Alan Dershowitz, one of the leading civil rights activists in our country,
提出建议使用刑讯委任制 所以至少让我们对私刑看远一点 raised the idea of using torture warrants so as at least to be more open about it.
刑讯委任制 我爱刑讯 Torture warrants. Love that torture.
Preston先生谈到该案的受害者是位无辜的人 Mr. Preston talks about the victim here being an innocent man.
看看吧 他并没那么无辜 Now, come on, he wasn't that innocent.
他的确帮助了个逃犯 一个绑架并杀死过孩子的逃犯 He did harbor a fugitive, one who kidnaps and kills children.
他的确知道什么 最后也通过这找到了孩子 He did have information that ultimately led to the rescue of the child here.
而他一开始拒绝说出来直到 And he refused to give it up until he was
他被强迫说出 coerced.
至于说到我的当事人凌驾于法律之上 As for my client being above the law,
你们看 这个国家的法律总是为了 well, the law in this country has always been subject to evolving
适应社会人性的标准 community standards of humanity.
你们12人的陪审团也会回到那做为社会的一部分 那么 问问你们自己 So the 12 of you get to go back there, as a community, and ask yourselves,
这是件好事还是坏事 was this a good thing or not
他很快乐 他还活着 He's happy. He's alive.
他们一家都一定很高兴 They're sure as hell happy.
我的当事人救了一个人的命 那个小男孩的命 My client saved a life, that little boy's life.
如果他是你们的孩子 If it were your child,
难道你们不想警察做所有他们能做的来找到孩子吗 wouldn't you want the police to do whatever was necessary
这位警官完成了自己的职责 This officer got the job done
通过使用一种我们的政府 我们的军队 我们的最高法官 using a method that our government, our military, our attorney general,
噢 对 还有我们的最高法院 都认为有时是可行的方法 and, yes, even our supreme court has said is sometimes okay.
有时 根据情况 刑讯是可行的 Sometimes. Depending on the situation, torture's okay.
但是别让任何人知道 Just don't tell anybody.
主席夫人 现在陪审团有决议了吗 Madam foreperson, the jury has reached a verdict
有了 阁下 请说 We have, your honor. What say you
我们支持原告 On the question of liability, we find in favor of the plaintiff.
关于赔偿 On the question of damages,
我们判定被告需向原告知付总额为160万美元的赔偿金 we order the defendant to pay the plaintiff the amount of $1.6 million.
谢谢 现在陪审团解散 Thank you. The jury is dismissed.
噢 我的天了 1.6 Oh, my god.
对不起 I'm sorry.
你说过我们会赢的 You said we'd win.
你第一个错误是在法庭上让我激怒你 Your first mistake was letting me push your buttons in there.
你第二个错误是没让你的当事人准备好 Your second was not preparing your client for cross.
他承认了错误 他承认了那伤害是可预见的 He admitted fault. He admitted the harm was foreseeable.
你让我界定了那是新郎的责任 You let me frame the issue as the groom's duty to be sure before the ceremony.
一旦我们界定了 我们就赢了 Once we got that, we won.
永远不要让你的对手界定什么 儿子 Never ever let the other side frame the issue, son.
我不是你儿子 I'm not your son.
你能离开吗 Could you please go
你第三个错误 Your third mistake
父亲的定义 the definition of a father
是很广的 it's a sliding scale.
有些很好 有些很坏 大部分界于其中 Some are great, some are terrible, and most are in between.
我也许在你身边的时候不多 I may not have been around much,
但在你需要我的时候我总在那 but I was always there when you needed me.
我一直是这样 Still I am.
我一直爱着你 And I've always loved you.
一直是 Still do.
请起立 Will the defendant please rise
陪审团得出判决了吗 The jury has reached a unanimous verdict
是的 阁下 请宣读你们的判决 We have, your honor. Please state your verdict.
在公诉Wayne Kirkland控诉其故意伤害一案中 In the matter of the Commonwealth versus Wayne Kirkland,
我们认定被告 read the charge of aggravated assault, we find the defendant Wayne Kirkland
无罪 not guilty.
恭喜 非常感谢 Congratulations. Thank you very much.
谢谢你所做的一切 别客气 先生 Thank you for everything. You're welcome, sir.
谢谢你 Alan Thank you, Alan.
我十分抱歉我曾冒犯过你 And I apologize if I offended you.
胡扯 你对我的律师技术帮助不少 Shirley Nonsense, you paid great tribute to my lawyering skill, Shirley.
还有什么比这更好的称赞吗 What higher compliment could there be
Alan 听着 我 Alan, listen, I .
你洞视黑暗的能力 我想我们每个人都有 也包括我 your capacity to see darkness, we all have it, I suppose, including me.
我的意思是 My point is
这是件棘手的工作而我选择你去做它 it was simply a dirty job and I chose to let you do it.
不 重点是我愿意做它 No, the point is I was willing to do it
而你只不过发现了这一点 and you somehow saw that.
你的秘书说你想见我 Your secretary said you wanted to see me.
她那么跟你说的吗 She told you that
有什么理由她不是那么说的吗 Is there some reason why she shouldn't have
我说的是我想见裸体的你 I said I wanted to see you naked.
我想那就不太可能了 I don't suppose there's much chance of that.
那我让你见我的 I'll let you see me naked.
那现在这也没什么可能性了 Now there's definitely no chance.
那么 你就呆在这吧 Well, now that you're here,
你做了个漂亮的案子 you tried a good case, soldier.
你是个出色的律师 You're an excellent lawyer.
谢谢 也和别人说一下这个 Thank you. Tell a friend.
不喊我一个人喝 Drinking without me
我从没少过你 I'm never without you.
不错的外套 新的吗 Nice coat. New
3500美金 $3,500.
有钱真不错 你喜欢有钱吗 It's good to have money. Don't you love having money
有钱意味着我们成功了 意味着快乐 It means we're successful. Happy.
肥胖罢了 Fat.
都好了 It's all good.
你的案子怎么样 How'd your trial go
赢了 你的呢 We won. You
胜了 Victory.
成功 Success.
能拿钱 Goes well with having money.
我们是胜者 我们本来就是 We're winners. That's what we are.
是 干杯 敬胜者 Yep. Salud. Here's to the winners.